Andrew Maguire's MetalsTrader service... good or bad?

I'm looking into possibly subscribing to Andrew Maguire's Metals Trader service, and wanted to see if anyone here uses it... I found another thread where Gold Dog and ACAD talk about their experiences, but there must be more people here who use the service or have tried it, given Turd's frequent recommendation of the service...

So can anyone else share their experience, especially recent experience? The little I've found so far on the interwebs suggests that the service used to be very good, but has become all but useless for day trading recently...

I wonder if this could be because it has become too popular, and so, depending on how quickly you receive the text from Maguire and execute your order relative to other subscribers, you could receive a much worse fill... or is there more to it?

Any thoughts and info are appreciated...