Comment search by poster (Turd in this example) looks to be redirecting after the 2nd page.
Note the address bar of the page, my curser (not visable) is on the "3" at the bottom of the page to move onto the 3rd page of Turd's comments & finally the address at the very bottom showing the destination of the link.
My bad, maybe FireFox acting up. :-/
Actually this is correct... "page 1" has no additional querystring on the URL, "page 2" should be shown as "?page=1" in the URL, "page 3" should be shown as "?page=2", and so on. The actual page will be one higher than the URL number.