The Consent of the Governed

Mon, Nov 25, 2013 - 2:12pm

“Government has become a paramecium, an amoeba whose prime directive is to grow and consume and multiply without knowledge of what it is supposed to be doing other than expanding. Or maybe the better metaphor is the zombie. The groping State smells those still alive and then plods and claws itself toward the few remaining living, in a mindless effort to incorporate or devour them. The zombie likes best the scent of the pizza franchiser or masonry contractor, not the welfare recipient or the Facebook executive.” (Link)


I have a neighbor who is a small farmer, and in addition to growing feed corn and raising beef cattle, he raises healthy, free-range chickens and sells a few hundred fresh eggs a week at farmers markets and “buy local” Co-ops. That is, he used to. He quit last year when new regulations for food safety (instituted at the behest of factory egg farms) required all sorts of new certifications, inspections, and expensive equipment to comply with the laws. Paying for all the things the new laws will require was only cost-effective for a large operation (thus driving small farmers out of the market, which was precisely why the large operations lobbied for the bill). Rather than do all that work for virtually no gain, he butchered his flock and just stopped producing.


Healthy young people, finally waking up to the fact that they are the financial pack-mules for Obamacare, have refused to sign up for the program in numbers that come anywhere close to balancing those they are supposed to subsidize. One wonders what they will do if they ever take a good, hard look at Social Security and Medicare: A double-earner couple (making the US median wage) who retired in 2010 will receive $310,000 more in benefits than they paid in to the system over the rest of their lives. The same couple, if the household was a single-earner married couple, will receive nearly half a million dollars more ($446,000) in benefits than they paid in during their lifetimes (Link). Just like Obamacare, the young are expected to produce in order to subsidize these costs. It will be interesting to see what happens if they ever figure this out.


Taxpayers, particularly successful middle and upper-middle class business owners, are deliberately managing their income levels by working less and precisely calculating how much they need to give to charity in order to fall below Federal tax thresholds. Many have simply decided that, given increasing taxation and regulatory burdens, it is no longer in their interests to run a business at all and have closed-up shop entirely (Link).


There is a property I particularly admire that I pass on my drive to work- beautiful fields, groves of woods along the property boundaries, and the whole thing gently sloping to the banks of a bend in the river. It used to be a working farm, but the family that bought it a few years ago realized that if they registered with the state as a farm and rented out the acreage, they would be subject to all sorts of restrictions and laws. Worse, the new “Food Safety Act” which is set to become law next year has granted unelected bureaucrats in numerous Federal agencies (from the FDA to the Department of Agriculture to the EPA) unprecedented control over privately held farmland, in particular the ability to force landowners to comply with expensive restrictions without recourse or appeal (Link). The choice was easy for the folks who own that farm- don’t farm anything, and don’t get on the watch list of half a dozen federal agencies. I think about how much that prime land could have produced as I drive past it. But I suppose there is a silver lining: eighty tillable acres that have been left fallow look quite pretty when the weedy grasses turn a golden tan in the fall.


California’s productive middle class, realizing that the social compact constructed by Sacramento over the last few decades is one where they have enormous financial obligations and regulatory burdens and receive precious little in return aside the privilege of contributing even more, have left the state in droves: you could literally populate the state of Montana three times over with the number of middle-class earners who have left the People’s Republic of CA over the last 20 years (Link).


Tri-City Herald, Kennewick WA: It took Bob Bertsch 25 years to build his construction business and just a day for it all to go away. Bertsch’s Ashley-Bertsch Group went on the auction block Friday at 9 a.m. By 4 p.m., Booker Auctions had sold off almost two dozen vehicles and trailers, tons of power tools and supplies, even the gas-fired fireplace in the office. Bertsch, 65, said he is down-sizing because the tax burden got too expensive to stay in business.

“I am tired of carrying all the tax load,” Bertsch said. “I renew 13 licenses here every year just so I can spend money in this city.” Bertsch makes no attempt to conceal his frustration with the costs government imposes on small businesses like his. “Government is killing small business. We used to have 24 employees at our peak. Now, all of those people who used to work here are in unemployment lines,” he said. (Link)


What does any of this have to do with precious metals investing? I am of the opinion that it has quite a bit to do with it, actually. In each of the above cases, you see a two-part dynamic at work. Part 1 is a political system and its allied bureaucracies treating the earnings, property, and labor of the citizenry as its piggy bank and plaything- a government/state which bases its very existence on successfully conducting a continual process of plunder in order to fund a continuous expansion of its own power. Part 2 is the response of individuals to the particulars of this process, the quiet refusal to play the role of serf to the feudal lords of the state. In each case, from closing a business to working/earning less to letting productive farmland lie fallow, the dynamic is the same. The state says “Your productivity is mine” and the individual quietly responds “No, it isn’t” and changes their behavior accordingly. These people are, in a very practical way, refusing to aid and abet this process. They are withholding their consent.

The ‘consent of the governed’ isn’t created simply because a political party manages to make enough promises to enough special interest groups to bring in enough campaign cash to buy enough political ads to deceive enough people to squeak out a narrow electoral victory. It doesn’t result from the ability of unelected bureaucrats to use the coercive power of government and law to enforce their will. At the core of it, the ‘consent of the governed’ rests on each individual citizen consenting (or not) to go along with the demands being placed on them. Refusing to consent doesn’t require armed resistance, or showy protests and signs, or loud confrontations. It doesn’t require breaking the law or going to jail. All it takes is a refusal to participate in the activity being controlled.

At this moment, western central banks are engaged in a process of funding massive expenditures through monetizing (directly or indirectly) government debt. They create more Euros or Yen, or Pounds, or Dollars out of thin air and each time they do, they devalue your paycheck, pension, retirement account, and the change in your pocket. I understand they have the legal right to do this. I understand they are appointed by the elected representatives of the people and that this supposedly gives them the moral and practical authority to do so. But I have not been asked and did not give my approval to this process. My money is nothing more than a marker for my productivity and saved value, my efforts and risks, and indeed a significant portion of my life – and these things are mine. I do not consent to them being plundered in this way. So I remove my money from their system, as much as I am able. I buy gold and silver.

More regimes have been brought, piecemeal, to their knees by what was once called “Irish Democracy,” the silent, dogged resistance, withdrawal, and truculence of millions of ordinary people, than by revolutionary vanguards or rioting mobs. –James Scott, Two Cheers for Anarchism (Princeton University Press, 2013)

Dogged resistance, withdrawal, and truculence.

Sounds good… I’m in.

About the Author


Nov 25, 2013 - 2:21pm



Nov 25, 2013 - 2:22pm


In my proper person :-)


Nov 25, 2013 - 2:47pm


Love the coveted Thurd position, I also like a fifth...

Nov 25, 2013 - 2:48pm


Great Post and Timely

Good Art as well

Nov 25, 2013 - 2:57pm

I paid more Federal Income Tax in 2006...

...than I declared in gross income in 2012 and 2013 combined. No more. I will no longer produce to pay for killing millions.

I used to have 19 emplyees with above average pay and health benefits. I will never employ anyone again.

Nov 25, 2013 - 3:02pm

Not a Time to be Meek

Great post Pining. I'm in too! This is not a time to sit back meekly and wait for others to act. We need to spread the word and let our actions (or lack thereof) speak for where we stand. Also - the problem is not just US centric - same issues here in Canada.

Nov 25, 2013 - 3:16pm


It is great you are out, but so sad that it has come to this.

Nov 25, 2013 - 3:22pm

Totally agree, Pining.

Yes, as I said last week, zombies are everywhere and taking total control.

Who wants to lead a politicized life where everything - and I mean everything - needs to be defended to the death? The only practical solutions I see are to withdraw or to separate. When you have nothing in common with your "opposition" why continue to try and live together peacefully when they have no such wish for you? Everything they do pisses me off. Their moral compass points South, mine points North. And, of course, they're so smug and uninformed my blood pressure just rockets so I walk away.

This is not a way to live a life.

Nov 25, 2013 - 3:23pm


A letter to Gallio from Seneca (4BC-65 AD): " All men, brother Gallio, are desirous to live happy, yet blind to the means of that blessedness. As long as we wander hither and thither, and follow not our guide but the dissonant clamour of those that call on us to undertake different ways, our short life is wearied and worn away amongst errors, although we labour to get us a good mind: there is nothing therefore to be more avoided than following the multitude without examination, and believing anything without judging. Let us inquire what is best done, not what is most usually done; and what planted us the possession of eternal felicity, not what is ordinarily allowed of by the multitude, which is the worst interpreter of truth. I call the multitude, as well those that are clothed in white as those in other colours; for I examine not the colours of the garments, wherewith their bodies are clothed: I trust not mine eyes to inform me what a man is; I have a better and truer light, whereby I can distinguish truth from falsehood. Let the soil find out the good of the soul; if once she may have leisure to withdraw unto herself, Oh! how will she confess, I wish all I have done were undone; and all I have said, when I recollect it, I am ashamed of it, when I now hear the like in others. These things below, whereat we gaze, and whereat we stay, and which one man with admiration shows unto another, do outwardly shine but are inwardly empty. Let us seek out something that is good, not in appearance, but solid, united, and best, in that which least appears: let us discover this. Neither is it far from us: we shall find if we seek it. For it is wisdom not to wander from that immortal , but to form ourselves according to his law and example. Blessed is the man who judgeth rightly: blessed is he who is contented with his present condition: and blessed is he who giveth ear to that immortal principle, in the government of life". > No Cross- No Crown, page 365-6, William Penn<.

Yes a long letter but casts a light on century's old "Going Galt". (Going Galt is a great topic, thanks)

Nov 25, 2013 - 3:32pm


love the art!

Nov 25, 2013 - 3:38pm

I'm lost

or perhaps after learning about derivatives, hypothecation, re-hypothecation among other things, this sh-t is just to0 mind blowing.

This can only mean a world financial collapse is inevitable. Am I wrong, or should I practice my return to sheeple exercises?

Chart Of The Day: How China's Stunning $15 Trillion In New Liquidity Blew Bernanke's QE Out Of The Water

Mr. Fix
Nov 25, 2013 - 3:40pm

10, I went Gault when Obama became president.

His agenda was obvious then, he intended to destroy the productive, while propping up the unproductive, until the whole system collapses. Every single decision has made his bend towards that end goal.

I am mildly concerned, that he is not on board with the “one world order”, because his recent actions indicate that he does not intend to be a part of it. I have no particular love for the Israeli leadership, but he just screwed them royally, and the banking cartel has become fractured.

I can't be sure how much longer the “endgame” can play out, but the current plan appears to leave nothing for America in the next chapter of world history.

Although the amount of backstabbing seems to be accelerating, the only constant is the demise of America.

Nice post Pining,

It seems to me that all options other than war are being taken off the table, And America will be handed over to its enemies, or simply annihilated.

Nov 25, 2013 - 3:45pm

Luxury tax notices sent out by Greek authorities

Notices for an increased luxury tax are being sent out this week by authorities, who are seeking to collect up to 130 million euros from the levy.

Owners of cars with an engine capacity of 1,929 cc or over, swimming pools, gliders, helicopters or airplanes are among those who will have to pay an extra tax.

The tax was first introduced in 2011 as a one-off but since then the levy has doubled and will now remain as a permanent fixture in the country’s tax code.

No, that won't lead to going Galt. No siree Bob.

Nov 25, 2013 - 3:47pm

But, Have WE LET Them

Do it to us? After all, we are supposed to be the "Great Experiment" of self-government. Is that concept beyond humanity's ability to achieve? Clearly, we, (collectively all who have lived as a citizen in this country), are at fault for letting it go this far down this "series of wrong turns". Many a "good man" has done nothing, (and many have fought to stop it, too), and so evil has prospered.

Now, how best do we repair the damage? I will not give in, so I must do what is best. But what is that? For each of us, the answer will be different, as we're all individuals, in unique situations. But collectively, we can be a powerful, constructive movement for repair of the damage, that for generations has slowly encroached on our lives & freedoms. Surely, it will take generations to reverse the damage & put us on the right road. That implies that we need to get involved with the education of our children and grandchildren, and our school systems. They are a train wreck, & so are only turning out economic slaves. Very few of our schools teach kids to think today.

"It's a job that's never started that takes the longest to finish."

J.R.R. Tolkien (1892 - 1973)

Great one, P4. Thank you.

"I wish it need not have happened in my time," said Frodo.
"So do I," said Gandalf, "and so do all who live to see such times. But that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us.”

J.R.R. Tolkien, The Fellowship Of The Ring

Sorry for the font size. How do I change that?

Nov 25, 2013 - 3:47pm

Tempted to go Galt

Your stories are quite sad, Pining, and oh, so common. My wife's real estate business was on the verge of hiring our first employee some years back before the 08 crisis began. We held back. Today it would be impossible. So we put our rental homes with a manager and are happy to get the small check left over each month.

I am privileged to live in a "green" town where self-sustenance is considered a virtue and a fair percentage of the population are actively trying to break free of some part of the system.

My wife just completed her master gardening class and we are planning to build a small bug-out home near a river about an hour away, plant orchards, and build greenhouses. I think I really could cut back to earning a poverty level salary once we have our small home built and the gardens up and running. In effect, we could drop out of the system while staying in plain sight.

I have become 100% sold on the idea of having a home paid off before this experiment ends. Otherwise, my family is subject to the whim of bankers or landlords. Even my state job at the University could get axed when the money presses stop the flow.

Nov 25, 2013 - 3:50pm


Are you John Galt?

"Pining Shrugged" . . . . .

Nov 25, 2013 - 4:01pm

Thank you Pining

Your article does a good job of explaining the process that I think is already occurring in this country, and that is likely to accelerate. Thank you Sir.

I've currently got a good job with a comfortable income. In about two or three years I expect to quit it, at the age of only 53 or 54, and start a lifestyle more in harmony with the land, something like Katie Rose's.

That'll deprive the government of hundreds of thousands of dollars in taxes they would have gotten if I had worked to my retirement age of 67. And I'll be much happier, eating much better from produce I grow myself, and living a much less stressful life.

The key line, IMHO:

. "The state says “Your productivity is mine” and the individual quietly responds “No, it isn’t” and changes their behavior accordingly."

Best Regards,


Nov 25, 2013 - 4:09pm

@Pining re: withdrawal . . .

"Dogged resistance, withdrawal, and truculence. Sounds good… I’m in."


I have been "in" for awhile. I was already making plans by 1998, as I was uncomfortable the way things were going then.

I starting surrendering my IRAs and 401-k monies, as well as my wife's (she thought I was ever-loving nutso, but went ahead) accounts in 2003, and used proceeds to 1. pay taxes and penalties; 2. buy physical gold and silver. We each still have one IRA apiece, but that, too will soon be withdrawn--and we are now beyond the penalty age. Unfortunately, all the metals were lost in a tragic boating accident some years ago; I hope to learn how to dive so I can retrieve them a bit at a time later on, when they are recognized as money again.

We also sold our suburban yuppie style home in 1999 and bought 40 acres on which we built a home, drilled a well, put up a solar electric system, planted a perennial vegetable/fruit garden, and rent to a local farmer who plants tomatoes, squash, pumpkins and sweet corn on it. We can take all the produce we want for ourselves, as per our rent agreement. We have a propane tank, a diesel storage tank, a diesel generator, and we have about 5 acres of woods which we trim for firewood.

I also planted an acre of hazelnut bushes, which gives us all the nut protein we want. I am thinking of having a couple dozen chickens as well, but haven't done it yet.

My 4 kids, 3 son/daughter-in-laws and 2 grandkids all live nearby. We have stocked away a lot of food, but not near enough for 11 people for an extended period, but hopefully, the gardens can provide.

We are trying to return to how Americans were able to earn a subsistence living similar to the early 1900's.

sierra skier
Nov 25, 2013 - 4:18pm

I have been in the Process For Years Now

I started several years ago to reduce my support towards feeding the beast. We are now ready to retire out of the liberal world of California. Though we love our incredible small town in the mountains it is located in California and has become more than we desire to handle. It is time to move on to a place where more like minded folks will be our neighbors. As much as I don't wish to leave 40 years of wonderful living we are being chased out of the state by those who run the place.

Great post Pining.

Swift Boat Vet tyberious
Nov 25, 2013 - 4:24pm

P4 Count me in too

I'm sure with you Pining. I've spent my whole working life self employed. If this country was anywhere near like it was a couple 3 or 4 decades ago, I'd start another business (What, I'm not sure) for myself and my youngest son, so he could just ease me out in a few years and I could maybe have that fancy "Emeritus" hung around my name. (???) As it is, we are both just stacking for the future. A reset should shrink government down to an almost non-pestering size. (hopefully)


Nov 25, 2013 - 4:29pm


We all need to go Gault. I am 95% there.

Nov 25, 2013 - 4:30pm


I was forced out, took a licking! Just no desire to get back in. Sometimes I miss the game, but the only way to win is to not play. I have learned how little we need in the way of consumer goods in order to live a very fulfilling life. I have learned how to protect the fruits of my labor from the parasites. I have learned to do more with less and more importantly that less is more. I have learned how to not want what I can't have. My relationship with the dollar was all an illusion. I have learned to cherish the relationships in my life.

transplanted baby
Nov 25, 2013 - 4:42pm

Pining, how did you feel

Pining, just curious. How did you feel when you saw the video clip a few posts back regarding "The Natural Man" who defended himself in court?-assuming you saw that. As you have taken a step toward being a natural man (I saw your chickens, months ago-here, not in person), could you relate to the man- or did you think he was off his rocker? (And what say you Mr Fix? ) That man was ahead of our (the turdville)curve- I mean it seemed to me that for him the end of this keynesian experiment has already happened-again for him and in his mind. Comments?

For everyone else, Flee to the fields or at least read the book.

And here just for a holiday chuckle, is an anecdote. I have a story about Independence Day that I read to my students and then have them answer some questions. I tried this with my young kids. In the story, there are repeated references to "the colonists". Anyway, the last question is, "Who won the war?" My young daughter blurted out....."the communists"! Her grandmother fell off her chair laughing, but if you think about it....

Nov 25, 2013 - 4:44pm


Your response gave me goose bumps. I have found less is more as well, and like you I think about the game, but when I talked to friends who are still it, I feel ahead of it. It is much more peace full living. We might just survive because of our knowledge.

Nov 25, 2013 - 5:22pm

@ pining4

Obviously you struck a nerve - or better yet - put in words what many here are thinking/doing. You have vocalized the (probably) predominate mind frame set here on the forum. Great word-smithing chum.

Thanks a bunch, from us all.

Nov 25, 2013 - 5:45pm

Great Piece, Pining !

I wonder if opting out is enough. We are still subject to sales tax and real estate tax and if you take the easy way out, they tax what you had because "you can't take it with you". They seem to have all of the bases well covered. In my view, the "State" has but one rule, that being : "We win and you lose." To make matters worse, there is more than one state. There are big, middle size and small.

My wife and I are giving serious consideration to taking a one way vacation to a warmer climate. It's somewhat strange but it's not just the cold but the heat as well. Where we live, it gets way hotter in the summer than it does in Puerto Vallarta or Cancun. Even Panama can be cooler in summer if you are willing to go up two or three thousand feet in elevation. Same for Cartagena, Colombia. Good health care is available at a fraction of US cost. Puerto Vallarta has a thriving medical and dental tourism market. We owned property in Cancun but sold it when the shooting started to close in on the tourist areas. (Acapulco is now a total loss.)

We still haven't made up our minds but every time big brother comes up with more crap, the closer we get. At the rate it's going, Bumfook, Egypt is starting to look better all the time.

Nov 25, 2013 - 6:07pm


I have visited Panama, Belize and Costa Rica. I thought CR was much better choice then the first two. Panama to me had Erie feeling and Belize government is as corrupt as ours.

Nov 25, 2013 - 6:20pm
Nov 25, 2013 - 6:29pm

just to follow-up on small business taxes

“I am tired of carrying all the tax load,” Bertsch said. “I renew 13 licenses here every year just so I can spend money in this city.” Bertsch makes no attempt to conceal his frustration with the costs government imposes on small businesses like his. “Government is killing small business...''

If yah really want to know how hard they hit an entrepreneur......................

Back in a previous life-time, during the mid '70's, I was a car dealer in NYS. I paid Twenty-Three taxes and licenses yearly. And we had to estimate our taxes quarterly, and pre-pay them. There was a fine for missing on the estimate.

I recall attending a NYS dealer convention in Syracuse, NY in '75, where our financial statements were reviewed (as a group) by a major NYC accounting firm. As a group were were averaging less than 2% net profit after taxes. I recall that the Chief accountant opened his remarks to the group by saying;

"I must be addressing the most egotistical bunch of people in the world. You guys must just like to see your name in neon lights. As a group, You are getting 2% return on your money. Furchissakes guys, NYC Bonds are paying 8% right now."

Mr. Fix
Nov 25, 2013 - 6:56pm

Have We Reached 'Peak Gold'?

Have We Reached 'Peak Gold'?

Submitted by Tyler Durden on 11/25/2013 - 18:39

Led by countries such as Russia and China, central banks have recently become net buyers of gold. Meanwhile, ETF gold outflows have been a temporary source of supply this year, but obviously this cannot persist. It’s also unreasonable to assume that recycling will make up a significantly greater piece of supply without the price of gold increasing substantially. With the grade of current producing gold mines being 32.6% higher than undeveloped deposits, it makes the supply scenario even more clear. Not only is the current yearly mine supply difficult to sustain, but future mines coming online will be challenged by grade and margins to be economical at today’s prices. Mathematically, unless we have high-grade, high ounce deposits that are being fast tracked online, it will be very difficult to find a way to get supply to match demand. Have we reached peak gold?


Donate Shop

Get Your Subscriber Benefits

Exclusive discount for silver purchases, and a private iTunes feed for TF Metals Report podcasts!

Key Economic Events Week of 5/13

TWELVE Goon speeches through the week
5/14 8:30 ET Import Price Index
5/15 8:30 ET Retail Sales and Empire State Manu. Idx.
5/15 9:15 ET Cap. Ute. and Ind. Prod.
5/15 10:00 ET Business Inventories
5/16 10:00 ET Housing Starts and Philly Fed
5/17 10:00 ET Consumer Sentiment

Key Economic Events Week of 5/6

5/9 8:30 ET US Trade Deficit
5/9 8:30 ET Producer Price Index (PPI)
5/9 10:00 ET Wholesale Inventories
5/10 8:30 ET Consumer Price Index (CPI)

Key Economic Events Week of 4/29

4/29 8:30 ET Pers Inc, Cons Spend, Core Infl
4/30 8:30 ET Employment Costs
4/30 9:45 ET Chicago PMI
5/1 8:15 ET ADP jobs report
5/1 9:45 & 10:00 ET Markit and ISM Manu PMIs
5/1 10:00 ET Construction Spending
5/1 2:00 ET FOMC Fedlines
5/1 2:30 ET CGP presser
5/2 8:30 ET Productivity and Unit Labor Costs
5/2 10:00 ET Factory Orders
5/3 8:30 ET BLSBS
5/3 9:45 & 10:00 ET Markit and ISMServices PMIs

Recent Comments

by SteveW, 1 min 23 sec ago
by Green Lantern, 28 min 49 sec ago
by Trail Trekker, 2 hours 29 min ago
by Turd Ferguson, 2 hours 44 min ago