A Specific Peculiarity

Tue, Jul 18, 2017 - 10:02am

For years, we've watched JPMorgan stockpile what is alleged to be physical gold and silver in their Comex vaults. However, something has changed over the past four months and we thought we should bring this to your attention today.

First some background...

During the silver price run-up of 2011, JPMorgan was seemingly caught flat-footed. They appeared to hold a massive paper short position while simultaneously holding no visible physical position. At the time, JPM did not have a Comex silver vault and, as the CFTC-generated Commitment of Traders data showed at the time, the last $10 of price surge was almost entirely due to a "commercial" short squeeze. The most likely "commercial" being squeezed in April of 2011? JPMorgan.

Also in the spring of that year, the was a rapid approval for JPMorgan to start their own Comex silver vault. Evidence of this can be found when we review how this vault came about in March of 2011. This old link details how JPM was suddenly and quickly approved to establish this new Comex silver vault: https://seekingalpha.com/article/259549-will-jpmorgan-now-make-and-take-...

After starting from ZERO in 2011, JPM has quickly amassed a horde of Comex silver and now has a virtual stranglehold and monopoly on this "market". As of last Friday, JPM's Comex silver vault held 112.5 million ounces versus a total Comex vault of 213.3 million ounces. This means that JPM now holds/controls nearly 53% of all silver backing the Comex silver paper derivative exchange.

To help you better understand the scope of this, check these next two charts (click to enlarge). First, here's an old Comex silver stocks report from June 3, 2011. Note the following:

  • Prior to JPM's inclusion in 2011, there had only been FOUR Comex silver depositories.
  • After the first 60 days or so, JPM had only brought in 750,761 ounces, all of it marked "eligible".
  • The total amount of silver held in all vaults was just 100,535,272 ounces.

This next chart I found on Twitter over the weekend and it comes from the always helpful Nick Laird at www.goldchartsrus.com. It shows in dramatic fashion the rising dominance of JPM and their silver vault on the Comex:

JPM seems to have largely amassed this horde through the steady acquisition of silver through the bi-monthly "delivery" process on the Comex. If we check the records since 2015, we see this play out. While only rarely issuing a contract, the House or proprietary account of JPM has consistently stopped (taken) "deliveries" since March of 2015. See below:

March15: JPM House stopped the position limit of 1,500 contracts. At 5,000 ounces/contract, this represents "delivery" of 7,500,000 ounces.

May15: 808 stops for 4,040,000 ounces

July15: 1,161 for 5,805,000 ounces

Sept15: 370 for 1,850,000 ounces

Dec15: 1,400 for 7,000,000 ounces

March16: 1,076 for 5,380,000 ounces

May16: 1,500 for 7,500,000 ounces

July16: 771 for 3,855,000 ounces

Sept16: 405 for 2,025,000 ounces

Dec16: 1,550 (50 contracts in excess of the 1,500 limit) for 7,750,000 ounces.

Adding this all together gives us a total 2015-2016 stoppage of 10,541 contracts for 52,705,000 ounces of silver. Over the same time period, JPM House issued just 342 contracts for 1,710,000 ounces. So, on a NET basis, the House account of JPMorgan accumulated almost precisely 51,000,000 ounces of silver in their Comex Vault over the time period of 2015-2016.

This hoarding continued into 2017 when JPMHouse stopped a whopping 2,689 contracts back in March. This represents a "delivery" of 13,445,000 ounces and is clearly WELL IN EXCESS of the stated Comex front and delivery month position limit of 1,500 contracts. We wrote about this at the time and even went so far as to file a complaint form through the CFTC website. You can read all about it here: https://www.tfmetalsreport.com/blog/8243/march-comex-silver-deliveries

Well a curious thing has occurred in the time since. After illegally stopping 2,689 contracts in March, the House account of JPMorgan stopped a grand total of ZERO Comex silver contracts in May and, thus far in July, they've once again stopped a total of ZERO.

Now why would this be? Does JPM finally feel as if they have enough silver? Did their violations back in March result in a slap in the wrist from the CFTC? Who can say for certain? What's clear, however, is that with a physical horde of 107,000,000 ounces in their eligible vault, JPM now has enough silver to physically settle and cover 21,400 Comex contracts should they ever begin to get squeezed again as they did in 2011. (This of course assumes that the entire 107MM ounces is owned/controlled by the JPM House account.)

Adding more intrigue to the question, however, is what we're also seeing in Comex gold. In 2015, the House account of JPM was actually a NET issuer of Comex gold contracts. Some months they issued and some months they stopped (took "delivery") and the result was an issuance of 1,109 Comex gold contracts for NET loss of 110,900 ounces of gold. This changed in 2016 though as the JPM House account ended up with a NET stoppage of precisely 8,000 Comex contracts for 800,000 ounces.

This continued into 2017 with February seeing 771 stops for a total of 77,100 more ounces. And then a curious thing happened here, too. The House account of JPM had a total of ZERO activity in April. No stops and no issuances. And then, when June came around, it happened again! No June gold stops and no June gold issuances! What the heck??

And so here we are. After being an active collector and hoarder of "physical" gold and silver through the bi-monthly Comex delivery process, the activity of the House account of JPM has suddenly come to a grinding and complete FULL STOP. And the question is: WHY? Why, after participating in every gold and silver "delivery" month for years, has the JPM House account suddenly ceased all activity? Again, are they "full"? Has the CFTC slapped a penalty upon them for repeatedly exceeding delivery month position limits?

Most importantly, what if anything might this mean for price? Has JPM conspired to keep prices low for years so that they could acquire metal as inexpensively as possible? Maybe. And, now that they appear to be "done", might price finally be allowed to rise? Again, maybe.

Unfortunately, all we can do is speculate. The actual answers will very likely never be known as the only thing that remains constant in the world of the paper derivative pricing scheme is the deliberate opacity of the process.



About the Author

turd [at] tfmetalsreport [dot] com ()


Jul 18, 2017 - 10:07am


Am I first?

Jul 18, 2017 - 10:15am

You are most definitely first

I'll take 2nd, or 3rd today, if I shut up and post.

My long trade is looking solid this morning. Just raised my stop. I seem to be more comfortable trading oly 25% of my account. Then I can relax, think, set reasonable stops, take profits, get back in, all without having to watch the charts all day. Good thing too... I have lots of work to do this summer as my son and I rebuild a home that he just bought.

One out of the nest, one more to go!

Jul 18, 2017 - 10:20am

JPM/Bear Stearns

as I understand it, when Bear failed and JPM grabbed Bear, it also grabbed the huge Bear short position in silver (which was rumored to be a chinese short position).

Anybody recall this?

Also, McHugh went to a buy signal on Gold et all last night, but he is confusing in that he calls for a nice rally and then a gold selloff to lower level, before truing back up and heading for new highs. He is also calling for a higher dollar and PM prices concurrently.

Jul 18, 2017 - 10:25am


All my miners are green this morning -- sweet!

Stack on!

Jul 18, 2017 - 10:50am

The Yen,

Looks like it is taking some sort of enhancement chemical. Tando

Jul 18, 2017 - 10:51am


USD/JPY , DXY both down big, gold and silver prices up. Why isn't the HUI and most miners responding in a higher percentage increase like they normally do? I am not being greedy, just making an observation.

EDIT: Most of my miner stocks seem to be capped at their respective long-term trend line (3-year). Seems very interesting that they couldn't gain the few cents on a day like today to overcome.

3-year trend line: AG, WPM, SAND, etc.

6-month trend line: MUX

Jul 18, 2017 - 10:58am

To your point, Mickey

WAY back in the day...like Feb/March 2011...I got an anonymous email from a guy who seemed to be legit. He claimed to be a former Bear trader and that he personally knew the whole "Bear's silver short was absorbed by JPM" story was NOT true. He said Bear had never maintained a short position in silver and that anyone who claimed otherwise was either misinformed or intentionally spewing misinformation. I've never forgotten this email and I'm sure I still have it tucked away in s folder somewhere.

Of course, this doesn't mean that JPM doesn't have or has never had a silver short position. This person was simply emphatic that the story of JPM "inheriting" the position from Bear was not true.

Jul 18, 2017 - 10:58am

When does AM unleash hell on the comex?

He says 250 tones, but wouldn't it be smart if you were really going to stick a hot poker up their ass you would have orders for at least 2x that amount

Jul 18, 2017 - 10:59am

China and JPM are full of it

With 6 year's worth of speculation

Untold hours of investigation

Proves we're near the singularity

Where causes are now correlation

Since JPM's known as the buyer

A billion ounces, maybe higher

They're part and parcel as they conspire

To rig the prices; box to wire

Angry Chef
Jul 18, 2017 - 11:02am

Jul 18, 2017 - 11:07am

Making steady progress

Not only is USDJPY sub 112, both the 10-yr and 30-yr are down 4 bps.

The emergency exit door is closing on The Spec shorts and they are getting near to a true religious experience.

Jul 18, 2017 - 11:09am


Maybe the excuse is they are using the indiscriminate unthinking algo across the board to maximize short profits against tbe serfs.

Jul 18, 2017 - 11:11am

Hui and the Miners

I wonder if the miners are being held within a reasonable level until they are ready for a MAJOR EXPLOSION IN THE PRICE OF GOLD AND SILVER!!! In my dreams!

Jul 18, 2017 - 11:11am

Beaten down miners

I read somewhere here at TFMR about a miner that was heavily beaten down this last GDXJ rebalancing. Of course I cannot find that comment (or maybe it was in the forums) now. If someone remember what miner it was plz tell me.
I would also appreciate if some of my fellow turidtes would share other good miners that were beaten down hard this last rebalancing. Thank you!

Jul 18, 2017 - 11:28am
Jul 18, 2017 - 11:29am

Chinese Theory

I like the hypothesis that JPM is fronting for China. China owns the former JPM vault. China owns the JPM buildings. what more evidence do you want/need?

Jul 18, 2017 - 11:38am

That has always been, and

That has always been, and continues to be, a plausible explanation for years.

The Chinese have a long history of selling down the paper price of wheat etc in order to drive the physical price lower for cheaper accumulation.

Jul 18, 2017 - 11:41am


Turd, I take it you thought about this over the weekend and decided against call buying?

Jul 18, 2017 - 11:50am

Actually, I simply haven't

Actually, I simply haven't had the time yet this week to do/organize anything.

Additionally, my primary concern with putting on a few trades is the distraction it would bring, and this is NOT the time for me to be distracted or biased. Really need a full focus on market events, at present.

Jul 18, 2017 - 11:50am

Chinese Theory, if true...

='s about makes me want to puke my fucking guts out.

Wouldn't Chiner need to make damn sure that nearly all this phyzz was on their soil before they destroyed us by pulling back the curtain?

Jul 18, 2017 - 11:53am

Butler, Bix, NIA

"These facts indicate that everyone at the top had to be aware that excessive gold and silver shorting was at the center of the Bear Stearns fiasco. Since the Feds requested JPMorgan’s assistance, there can be no question that JPMorgan demanded (and received) permanent immunity from future gold and silver allegations. This explains how they have been able to establish market corners in gold and silver today that commodity law prohibits. Had not the U.S. Treasury Secretary, the Fed chairman, the CFTC, and the CME agreed to JPMorgan’s takeover of Bear Stearns’ gold and silver positions, the excessive market concentration and manipulation in these markets could not have continued. "


"It's all about extricating JP Morgan from the silver short position they were REQUIRED to take on by the US Treasury after the collapse of Bear Stearns."


NIA went on to say, "The reason why we believe the Federal Reserve was so eager to orchestrate a bailout of Bear Stearns, is because Bear Stearns was on the verge of being forced to cover their silver short position." NIA then said, "JP Morgan still holds the silver short position they inherited from Bear Stearns" and "JP Morgan will have to cover this short position or it could jeopardize their existence."


You can even find quotes from Andy, quoting Ted. So it looks like this was speculation from Ted Butler.

Jul 18, 2017 - 12:01pm

Yes it was

The theory that JPM was forced to assume the "massive silver short position" was first put forth by Ted Butler and repeated far and wide from there.

This does NOT change the idea of JPM being a major silver shorter, it just calls into question the how and why they got involved.

Jul 18, 2017 - 12:06pm

A brief check in...

...great post Craig !

I cannot say that I have any real answers or contributions to the topic at hand but I do believe that there is no way that JPM or their consortium will be wrong footed again. And it is this that saddens me most.

I am not a vengeful sort but I sure wouldn't mind to see criminals get their comeuppance. The evidence seems clear to those who view this matter with an open and informed mind and the bottom line is that MANY have been harmed greatly due to the criminality of the banks and the complicity of the negligent regulators.

Will I be joyous to see Ag at 50 or 100 ? Sure, but my joy will be muted knowing that the criminals are making out like bandits (once again). Will there/can there ever be REAL justice for these crooks ???? I am saddened to think NOT.

Jul 18, 2017 - 12:07pm
Jul 18, 2017 - 12:18pm


is hiding the weakness in todays stock market, and other FANG stocks doing fine.

Kroger is floating a bond issue to cover its pension funding-methinks we are going to have a massive liquidity crisis.

On the Silver issue with Bear Stearns, thanks Craig, now I remember Butler talking about that possibility. Who the heck knows what is reality anymore.

Jul 18, 2017 - 12:42pm

wo ho ho it's magic

Like we've never seen this happen before...

Jul 18, 2017 - 12:44pm
Jul 18, 2017 - 12:53pm


The beat down in GDXJ also affected miners too small to be considered in the GDXJ since so many people including myself do "arbitrage" in the miners. The best deal in my opinion now is New Carolin Gold (LAD on TSX and LADFF on OTC) - extremely low priced because of the market and also because a fund in Montreal had to sell. They just put out a new presentation and they've got drilling starting - this week I think.

Jul 18, 2017 - 1:28pm


FYI: Check this out and consider what might be coming your way.........


Angry Chef
Jul 18, 2017 - 1:31pm

USS Liberty: 'Operation Cyanide': Russians to the rescue

"the involvement of the Russian ship that came to the rescue of the USS Liberty, and saved it from being "finished off" by way of an American torpedo and sunk ".


This time we can all agree. The RUSSIANS DID IT !!!!


Donate Shop

Get Your Subscriber Benefits

Exclusive discount for silver purchases, and a private iTunes feed for TF Metals Report podcasts!

Key Economic Events Week of 5/20

5/20 7:00 pm ET CGP speech
5/21 10:00 ET Existing Home Sales
5/22 2:00 ET FOMC minutes
5/23 9:45 ET Markit PMIs
5/24 8:30 ET Durable Goods

Key Economic Events Week of 5/13

TWELVE Goon speeches through the week
5/14 8:30 ET Import Price Index
5/15 8:30 ET Retail Sales and Empire State Manu. Idx.
5/15 9:15 ET Cap. Ute. and Ind. Prod.
5/15 10:00 ET Business Inventories
5/16 10:00 ET Housing Starts and Philly Fed
5/17 10:00 ET Consumer Sentiment

Key Economic Events Week of 5/6

5/9 8:30 ET US Trade Deficit
5/9 8:30 ET Producer Price Index (PPI)
5/9 10:00 ET Wholesale Inventories
5/10 8:30 ET Consumer Price Index (CPI)

Recent Comments

by Craigo, 2 hours 4 min ago
by scoremore, 3 hours 28 min ago
by scoremore, 3 hours 48 min ago
by Wizdum, 3 hours 58 min ago
by scoremore, 5 hours 15 min ago
by Sound Money Minnow, 5 hours 23 min ago