Comex Conundrum

Mon, Nov 30, 2015 - 6:47pm

For a fair and honest market, the latest developments might be significant and noteworthy, perhaps even troublesome. But remember, we're not talking about a fair and honest market, we're talking about The Comex, instead.

As the "delivery month" of December begins on the Comex...and before we begin another exercise detailing what a sham, charade and illusion this all is...please take a few moments to review the links below. This is hardly the first time we've tried to draw attention to all of this and it likely won't be the last:

  • Again, the only reason that the Comex price for gold (and silver) has any relevance whatsoever is the alleged physical delivery that takes place at the price "discovered" through the trading of paper derivatives. Without physical delivery, the only "price" that is being discovered is the price of the paper derivative contract, itself. Thus, physical delivery is what gives relevance to the paper derivative price.

    So, what happens when the Comex "delivery" process is exposed as a fraud, an illusion and a charade? Does this mean that the Comex paper derivative price can no longer be the basis for physical pricing worldwide? YES IT DOES! That, my friend, is the reason we so diligently chronicle this stuff month after month. And, boy oh boy, it sure looks like December 2015 is going to be a doozy.

    The actual delivery phase of the December Comex gold contract began back on Friday when the Dec15 futures contract "expired". Though it still trades through December, as of today (Monday) any entity still holding a Dec15 contract had to supply 100% margin for the full cost of the contract or about $107,000. Why? Because, as a long holder of a contract in its delivery period, you are subject to having the metal delivered to you at any time and, at a price of $1070/ounce, 100 ounces will cost you $107,000.

    But the Comex market isn't about delivery, it's about paper derivative trading. So, by the close of business last Friday, nearly all traders had liquidated their Dec15 contracts and rolled them into the next "front month", which is the Feb16. However, some contracts always remain open at "expiration" and a few of these actually look to "stand" and "take delivery". For Comex gold, here's how it has played out in 2015:


    DEC14 11,507 3,381 or 29.4%

    FEB15 8,455 1,174 or 13.9%

    APR15 7,348 2,801 or 38.1%

    JUN15 8,380 2,959 or 35.3%

    AUG15 9,215 5,113 or 55.5%

    OCT15 3,092 950 or 30.7%

    DEC15 7,849 ?

    Note the outlier and dramatic dropoff of total deliveries back in October. This was likely due to the fact that October is typically the lowest volume delivery month of the year. However, recall that total Comex registered gold has been falling to new alltime lows as 2015 progressed, too. Could this be having an impact?

    Here are some random CME Gold Stocks reports. Check the date and the amount of gold listed as registered and available for delivery.

    This from December of last year. Enough gold for 7,378 deliveries (if deliveries were actually made):

    This from February of this year. Enough gold for 8,099 deliveries:

    This from last April. Enough gold for 6,031 deliveries:

    This from August. Now only enough gold for 4,888 deliveries:

    And, uh-oh, this from October. Only enough gold for 1,616 deliveries. Good thing only 3,092 stood and just 950 total deliveries were made, huh?

    So now here we are. The biggest and typically busiest delivery month of the year (December) is upon us and, at expiration last Friday, the Comex still had 7,849 contracts open and standing. And how many ounces of registered gold are currently available within the Comex vaulting system? As of today, total registered gold has fallen to a new all-time low of 134,877 ounces or enough gold to physically settle just 1,348 contracts!

    See what I mean? What a conundrum! IF The Comex truly was a free and fair market and IF actual physical metal deliveries were taking place to "back up" the paper derivative price, The Banks and The Exchange would be in a bit of a jam. From where would they find the gold needed to physically settle all of those seeking delivery?

    Ah, but no worries, I'm sure that the month of December will pass without any issues. There will be some small journal entry movements of gold back and forth between the categories and between The Banks. But no real gold will move and no real crisis will emerge. Instead, it will just be business as usual and CNBS, BBG et al will keep reporting the Comex paper price as the true "price" and "value" of gold.

    And this draws us back to the questions posed at the beginning of this post:

    • So, what happens when the Comex "delivery" process is exposed as a fraud, an illusion and a charade?
    • Does this mean that the Comex paper derivative price can no longer be the basis for physical pricing worldwide?

    The answer earlier was an emphatic "YES IT DOES!" and that's still the case. You, as a gold investor, need to understand this important point. One day soon, this current paper derivative and fractional reserve bullion banking pricing scheme will fail. Maybe not this month and maybe not in 2016, either. But fail it will. That much is a certainty. And when it does, gold will have to be priced based upon physical availability at the offer. Call me crazy, but I suspect that physically-discovered price is going to be considerably higher than the one discovered through the current paper derivative system, a scheme that levers physical gold into paper at a ratio of nearly 300:1. How much higher will the new price be? Hmmm...well let's just say that it's not going to be $1070/ounce, that's for sure.

    Therefore, prepare accordingly.


    About the Author

    turd [at] tfmetalsreport [dot] com ()


    Nov 30, 2015 - 4:47pm

    Caught ...

    totally unprepared with a witty medal winning post.

    Dragged my feet so long, I'll be lucky to finish Thurd!

    wax off

    Nov 30, 2015 - 5:05pm

    Holy Cow!



    Nov 30, 2015 - 5:09pm

    Maybe My Favorite

    4th?????? Dang 3rd, O! Well. Keep Stacking

    Nov 30, 2015 - 5:13pm


    Any comments on the COT?

    Sorry Marchas I stole your spot.

    Nov 30, 2015 - 5:27pm


    They will simply offer cash settlement for the deliverable Au that cannot be accessed, right?

    Nov 30, 2015 - 5:56pm

    when the COMEX cracks

    Maybe a re-pricing of $50,000/oz, as per Santa's prediction?

    (Swineflogger, brother pig!)

    Nov 30, 2015 - 6:27pm

    "Cash settlement" isn't

    "Cash settlement" isn't really the right term...unless, of course, there are shady backroom deals being worked out.

    Instead and far more likely, the difference between expiry OI and total deliveries is the amount of gold contracts sold or covered by the holder during the delivery month.

    For example, in October 3,092 stood yet only 950 deliveries were made. Was this some "cash settlement" where holders took some kind of premium to walk away? Some analysts claim this but I've never believed it. Instead, it's far more likely that 2,142 October contracts were simply closed out during the month as the contract continued to trade at full 100% margin. 

    We're some of those 2,142 coerced and made "an offer they couldn't refuse" in a mafia sense? Maybe. But I highly doubt that cash premiums are paid simply because it's too much money and word of the scheme to extort money from the shorts would quickly spread.

    Nov 30, 2015 - 6:47pm
    Nov 30, 2015 - 7:37pm

    Yet as they print more US dollars

    Yet as they print more US dollars the dollar gets stronger. It keeps going UP UP UP.

    Therefore, you'd think as they print more gold, gold should also be going UP UP UP.

    Not so.

    Weird, isn't it?

    Nov 30, 2015 - 11:31pm

    But this is pretty fishy

    Adding to the charade/sham/illusion...

    For the first delivery day for Dec15 silver (Friday), there were 2,746 deliveries posted and, for today, preliminary total Dec15 silver open interest falls by 2,836. Makes sense. Sounds pretty good right? Looks legitimate, yes?

    But check this out. For Friday's first delivery day in the Dec15 gold, there were only 2 deliveries posted. However, in what should be no surprise, today's preliminary OI for the Dec15 gold shows a drop of 1,996 contracts.

    Wall-e TF
    Dec 1, 2015 - 2:59am

    Why Dilution?

    What is the role of "the COMEX vault"? Stories on dilution (294:1, etc.) always imply that if the metal is not in the COMEX vault, it doesn't exist. The entire basis of the dilution claim is this fuzzy implication. 

    But, if trading via COMEX, can one supply directly or "just in time", for "efficiency argument X" (taxes?), making the "COMEX vault" contents at any time an irrelevant, useless measure?

    i.e., Sellers on can ship to buyers directly OR ship to warehouse for fullfillment by Amazon, if they don't want to deal with delivery. Whether a listed item is in the Amazon warehouse or not has no bearing on whether it exists and can still be delivered.

    Dec 1, 2015 - 9:14am

    ZH uses "dilution"

    I prefer the term "leverage", as in how many times available gold on hand has been levered into paper gold.

    Dec 1, 2015 - 10:47am


    I suspect one of the Zerohedge Tylers is a member here and reads all Craig's articles. When she or he sees something noteworthy, they re-write the support for Craig's thesis in their own words, pull up similar charts, without quoting so they don't have to give credit. Strictly speaking, it is not plagiarism, but it is "bad form" for a writer/analyst to steal a thesis. They should at least give a nod Craig's direction, insert a hyperlink, and then add their own significant contribution to the article.

    In the big picture...nobody owns the truth and I am happy to see good information get a wider audience...

    Dec 1, 2015 - 11:03am

    Gold Is the Dollar’s Achilles Heel

    Hongbing Song, in his book, written in Chinese in 2007,

    The Currency Wars – China and the new world order, says,

    “The dollar bubble seems gigantic at first sight,

    but its mortal acupuncture point is trust,

    and gold is the piercing point of this trust.”

    Dec 1, 2015 - 11:10am
    renozep Doctor J
    Dec 1, 2015 - 1:31pm

    @ Dr. J re: Tyler's following Craig

    Yes, I have thought that myself on several occasions. The timing and content 

    just too close. Pretty lame and very bad form at best.

    Dec 1, 2015 - 3:18pm

    And we have a new record!!

    Another 13,910 oz of registered gets reclassified to eligible today. This drops total Comex eligible down to another new record low of just 120,967 troy ounces and it sets a new all time high for BB leverage at 324:1

    Become a gold member and subscribe to Turd's Vault


    Donate  Shop

    Get Your Subscriber Benefits

    Exclusive discount for silver purchases, and a private iTunes feed for TF Metals Report podcasts!

    Key Economic Events Week of 1/14

    1/15 8:30 am ET Producer Price Index
    1/15 8:30 am ET Empire State Mfg. Index
    1/16 8:30 am ET Retail Sales
    1/16 8:30 am ET Import Price Index
    1/17 8:30 am ET Housing Starts
    1/17 8:30 am ET Philly Fed
    1/18 9:15 am ET Capacity Utilization and Ind. Prod.

    Key Economic Events Week of 1/7

    1/7 10:00 ET ISM Services Index
    1/7 10:00 ET Factory Orders
    1/9 2:00 ET December FOMC minutes 
    1/10 Speeches from CGP, Goons Bullard and Evans
    1/11 8:30 ET CPI

    Key Economic Events Week of 12/31

    1/2 9:45 am ET Markit Manu PMI
    1/3 10:00 am ET ISM Manu Index
    1/4 8:30 am ET BLSBS
    1/4 9:45 am ET Markit Serv PMI

    Recent Comments