The Inherent Unfairness of The Comex

Mon, Oct 19, 2015 - 7:55am

Once again, paper metal prices on the Comex are being set up for a smash. The Cartel Banks, acting as de facto "market makers" are issuing huge amounts of new paper contracts in order to sop up speculator demand and squash momentum.

Please take a moment to understand how a "normal" market works. Let's take an individual equity as an example.

Company XYZ has a outstanding float of shares that totals 1,000,000. On any given day, news flows and other events motivate the holders of XYZ to either buy, hold or sell their shares. In this example, let's say that something fundamentally positive occurs for XYZ. As investor scramble to buy XYZ shares, price rises. Why? Because there is a set amount of 1,000,000 shares on the market, price must rise to a point where existing shareholders are willing to sell, at which point a new price equilibrium is reached. The same is true when price falls. There are more sellers than buyers and price must fall to the point where buyers emerge and a new price equilibrium is found. The key in both situations is the finite amount of shares available. Yes, a company can do secondary offering and issue more shares but these things take weeks to organize with legal and underwriting concerns. Therefore, on any given day, the float and available "stock" to buy or sell static and finite.

OK. Sounds good. Are you with me so far?

However, sometimes things can get disorderly. Back in the old days, the NYSE has people called "Specialists". At their own risk (and profit), these folks were responsible for maintaining their own large block of an equity for the purpose of "making a market" should there ever be a complete absence of buyers or sellers. These Specialists were charged with being the buyers or sellers of last resort and thus "making a market" and keeping things orderly. The key though was that these specialists were only dealing with existing shares that they already owned. They did not and could not simply issue new shares in response to investor/speculator demand. As noted above, the float was finite on any given day and the "market" simply had to respond by moving price up or down in response to demand.

Now, compare and contrast this with how the CME Group allows the Bullion Banks to manage the Comex metals "markets". Many system apologists claim that The Banks, in managing the Comex paper derivative markets, are only acting in this same, benevolent "market maker" role. These folks claim that these altruistic Banks simply seek to provide an orderly and fair market filling the same role as the NYSE Specialists of days gone by. But here's the critical difference:

Instead of dealing with a finite supply of paper metal contracts, the Cartel Banks are able to simply issue brand new paper contracts whenever they'd like. If demand for Comex paper surges due to fundamental or technical reasons, price does NOT have to rise to a new equilibrium where existing holders are willing to sell. Instead, The Banks simply create new contacts...increase the order to meet the demand. Price rises are muted and momentum is contained. Price never breaks out and rises significantly in a single day like an equity might. An individual stock might rise 10% or 20% in single day due to news and information. But when was the last time you ever saw gold or silver do that? And why is this? Because of The Banks' ability to meet demand through the issuance of brand new paper contracts anytime they wish.

Now some folks will say that this is all perfectly fair and that The Banks are only hedging or selling what they currently have. If that's the case, then how do you explain the action of just Wednesday and Thursday or last week?

Up until Wednesday, gold had struggled to move through its 200-day moving average, which is a key technical indicator for speculators large and small. Early on Wednesday, price finally surged through the 200-day and this set off a surge of demand for paper gold contracts as technical trading and hedge funds looked to capitalize on this positive momentum. However, unlike the "fair" markets described above where prices rise to the point where sellers of existing shares (contracts) emerge, this speculator demand was met with a rush of freshly printed new contracts from The Banks. How many? On Wednesday, the total open interest for Comex gold rose by 15,774 contracts. This means that in order to meet demand, the "market making" Banks stepped in and simply created new supply. Ask yourself this...How much farther would prices have risen on Wednesday if The Banks hadn't added this fresh supply of 15,774 contracts? Another $10? Maybe another $20? Unfortunately we'll never know.

On Thursday, with price still comfortably above the 200-day, speculator demand for paper gold continued unabated. As price churned another $8 higher, The Banks added another 6,698 contracts of open interest. Again, how much higher would price have risen if it were forced to simply find an equilibrium where buyers finally found willing sellers of existing contracts? Another $10? Maybe another $20? Unfortunately, we'll never know.

And here's where it gets completely unfair and traders everywhere should question the legality of the process. By adding 22,472 new paper gold contracts over just two days, The Banks created brand new paper obligations for 2,247,200 ounces of gold as each contract represents an obligation to deliver 100 troy ounces. However, no gold was added to the Comex vaulting system over these two days. All The Banks did was create new paper obligations on fully 1/3 of ALL THE GOLD in the Comex vaults. As of Tuesday October 13, the entire Comex vault system held just 6,704,069 ounces. On Thursday October 15, though the total Comex gold open interest had risen by 22,274 contracts, the vaults still held just 6,704,069 ounces. See below:

So, again, in order to meet demand, squash momentum and contain price, The Banks on the Comex were allowed to create new paper obligation representing more than 1/3 of all the gold held on deposit in the Comex vaulting system. Again, how is this fair? How is this even legal?

And lest you think this is the first time this has ever happened, I urge you to click the link below:

That post was written on January 27 of this year after a similar travesty. As price broke the gate and rallied nearly 10% in January, The Banks responded by issuing a whopping 82,910 new contracts between January 2 and January 26, almost all of them soaked up by eager speculators looking to buy paper derivative exposure to gold. This essentially meant that The Banks sold over 8,000,000 ounces of paper gold to meet speculator demand and contain the new year price breakout to just a little over $100. IF the supply of contracts had been held constant and IF price had been forced to find an equilibrium between buyers and sellers of existing contracts, how much higher would have gold surged? To $1400? To $1500? Maybe even farther? And how might this have changed the narrative for 2015? Instead, price was contained and momentum was slowed. Once price was finally maneuvered back lower and below the 200-day moving average following the January employment report of February 6, the bottom dropped out. All of the speculators which bought in January were quick to sell in February. The Banks bought back nearly all of the paper contracts they had issued in January and total open interest was back to early January levels by February 13. Price, which began the year at $1184 and then rose to high of $1308 on January 22, fell back as well. By February 13, it was back to $1226 on its way to a March 17 low of $1148.

What's the takeaway of all of this? Well, besides the fact that The Comex is inherently and structurally unfair, you must be aware that price is going to be smashed again soon, just as it was in January. The Banks do not have the ability to deliver on their obligations so they'll need to cover them all back up just as they did last February. They'll want to do so at a profit so you must expect to see paper price rigged lower again, down and through the same 200-day moving average. Once this happens, the brainless and computer-controlled speculators will rush to the exits and sell back to The Banks the very same contracts the Banks sold to them last week. Price will fall sharply and all of these recent price gains will have been for naught.

Of course, there's always the possibility that something dramatic will happen and that prices will rise, instead. However, far more likely is the possibility that The Banks will soon raid price in order to drive it back under the 200-day moving average. Therefore, be on the lookout for lower prices ahead. Traders should use this foreknowledge to position themselves for the move and stackers should be on the lookout for the next "sale".

Remain optimistic but realistic and prepare accordingly.


About the Author

turd [at] tfmetalsreport [dot] com ()


· Oct 19, 2015 - 7:58am

As you can tell, this was written on Saturday

I'll be out most of the day Monday but will return in time to record and post a summary podcast in the usual time slot.

Wishram · Oct 19, 2015 - 8:05am

Thanks - prices look to be

Thanks - prices look to be teetering!

AlienEyes · Oct 19, 2015 - 8:13am

Duce ?

Two ?

cashonly · Oct 19, 2015 - 8:19am

our focus is on PMs

Even though our focus is on PMs, the COMEX contains some pretty hefty commodities such as wheat, corn, cotton, etc. Could the COMEX be nothing more than a tool of control? I seem to remember a few years back that there was a terrible global cotton harvest. Free market thinkers were stating textiles could rise 50% or more but no real price increase ever was seen. Same with the corn harvest in the U.S. in 2014, terrible harvest but somehow prices where 'managed'. One could make the tinfoil like assumption that any commodity who's price could have a negative effect on the economy can be controlled through the COMEX as seen with the PMs today.

G-Rod · Oct 19, 2015 - 8:41am


I think that the prices are finding support at 1170 and 15.90.

And I'll stick with that story until evidence contradicts it!

(Hmmm ... how long will that take?)

LostMind · Oct 19, 2015 - 8:43am
Joseph Warren · Oct 19, 2015 - 9:21am

Excellent Summary

now the real question, to me anyway, - is why and how PM 'prices' would ever be allowed to rise in such a system ? (That's what we all hope for, don't we ? ) The sole purpose of this market seems to be the protection of the bankster' fiat dollar, which is their key to maintaining their wealth & power.

Is the current financial system, and thus the political system, and thus the social system - now so fragile that they cannot allow people to move out of dollars and into PMs ? Its fragile enough that they can't raise interest rates - - ever

My view of PMs has changed over the years - from speculation, to investment, to insurance against economic break down.

LostMind · Oct 19, 2015 - 9:31am

Agree totally JW!

I use to view Silver and Gold as jewelry and "stuff" hawked by people who couldn't sell used cars...

Now, I'm a believer! But that all changed in 2006-2009. What I witnessed showed me the end game and it was not going to be good for anyone I knew!

PM's are a hedge, take your cash into the casino and try and make it work for you. But, make sure you have everything you need at home... See the attached movie trailer.... YIKES!!!!!!!!!!!!

AND, if you want even more manipulation.... Take your pick -in one convenient article (Women's rights. women lib, food scarcity, anti-men, prostitution)

· Oct 19, 2015 - 9:38am

Podcast update

Am a volunteer scorekeeper today at a girls state golf tournament. Things are already running behind. Therefore, today's podcast will most definitely not be posted on time.

Thanks for your patience.

Mr. Fix · Oct 19, 2015 - 9:42am

Did anybody say life is fair?

Life is inherently unfair, it's just more noticeable these days. The good guys are getting creamed, and the criminals are firmly in charge.

Life as we know it is about to change radically, at least that's the plan. Are you prepared?

Your best course of action is to learn how to survive without the system. A systemic collapse is inevitable, we have the good fortune of knowing that before hand.

We can't know yet how this will all unfold, it is a war, and the victors have not yet been established.

This is nothing less than a war against humanity, and a war against consciousness. Waking up to the evils that confront us will greatly increase our chances of survival.

Pay attention, take it a day at a time, and do the best you can. Fear is deadly, so don't go there. Many of their well laid plans have already collapsed, and I believe the powers that be are greatly overreaching with their arrogance and hubris.

Hang in there. 

Great article Craig. yes

AIJ · Oct 19, 2015 - 9:46am

Are you sure we should be talking about

gold is manipulated conspiracy stuff?

CPE · Oct 19, 2015 - 9:48am


I just caught up on the weekend threads, do you really need to bring all of that onto this new one?

AIJ CPE · Oct 19, 2015 - 9:54am


Yes. I only politely mentioned what Willie and Dr Janda talk about and I got excoriated. Just pointing out glaring contradictions on this board. Now I am going to join SS121 for a well deserved vacation.

CPE · Oct 19, 2015 - 9:59am


noted, cya.

Roy Rogers - Happy trails
Joseph Warren · Oct 19, 2015 - 9:59am

@ Lost Mind & Mr Fix - great posts

I think what is so tough for many people isn't the widespread criminal corruption - that was always there & has happened throughout history in many places. What was really tough for me years ago, was realizing that many of my long held beliefs were illusions. 

People identify with their beliefs. They think if they give them up, they themselves will no longer exist either. Its a difficult thing to resolve and most people avoid it. Being a PM holder takes a desire to look at the truth and the courage to re-examine your beliefs constantly. 

brokerk22 · Oct 19, 2015 - 10:02am

How many

painful days of agonizing fake markets must we endure? I am afraid to many.

· Oct 19, 2015 - 10:03am


As long as I see gold capped at its 200 day MA then the banks are still in control. they have an agenda that should be clear to all of us by now. "Gold, thou shalt not rise."

So I bought JDST this morning with a $1 trailing stop in hopes to fatten my retirement account which is forced into the markets. And I'll keep shorting paper gold as long as these illegitimate frauds are in control. In the meantime, we will continue to stack with any fiat we earn at these absurdly low prices and watch world events, the local economy, and batten down our hatches for the tidal waves that are surely coming.

Just took a look at prices of ETFs. Dang! I almost got stopped out already. These markets are unbelievable. I really shouldn't trade at all.

AIJ · Oct 19, 2015 - 10:04am

Differing opinions

The indignation always amazes me.

I feel fortunate to count both Jim and Dave as friends. This does NOT mean that we all believe the same things. This does NOT mean that we agree on everything. This also does NOT mean we can't be friends.

What is it about the internet that keeps people from understanding that?

StevenBHorse · Oct 19, 2015 - 10:15am

Your stops are fair game to the bots

If you want to trade these markets, then you need to watch the tape like a hawk. No stops. If you don't have that kind of time to devote to it, you shouldn't be doing it. You will not do yourself any favors setting stops in this market structure.

Joseph Warren TF · Oct 19, 2015 - 10:18am

RE: Differing opinions

Well said Craig yes

Good friends with well argued & supported different opinions than mine, are a gift. They may point out errors in my thinking, or personal blind spots.

That could save my life, health, or wallet wink

lakedweller2 · Oct 19, 2015 - 10:24am


Tunnel Vision. No pill to fix it.

brentb · Oct 19, 2015 - 10:52am


Many of the miners have gaps to the up side from 10/2 and 10/5 including the XAU and the HUI. These I think will be filled in this next correction in Gold and Silver before we can go back up.

· Oct 19, 2015 - 10:54am

@ Horse

That makes sense. I just closed with a nice profit, but your comment had me watching and remembering how many times they run the price down to hit the sell stops just before it takes off. Pullback in AU just as Turd suspected. I don't think they are done yet.

mike97 · Oct 19, 2015 - 11:17am

Warning shot across the bows?

Is this the takedown or a warning shot? I sold my silver stock traders first thing this morning. Will the takedown continue today or is the real attack later this week? The cartel has a lot of paper shorts to cover.

canary · Oct 19, 2015 - 11:19am

I wish I was farming black swans....

...and let them free today........Criminals....I'm sure they're smiling now.

James Crighton Mr. Fix · Oct 19, 2015 - 11:37am

@Mr Fix - " fear "

Mr Fix - I truly have no fear. Just a deep, deep hatred for the banksters and complicit politicians and "elites".

And the only thing that will put that hatred to rest is to see them getting their just pusishment - the details of which I will leave to those that have been most wronged by these despicable excuses for human beings.


lund175 Mr. Fix · Oct 19, 2015 - 11:40am

China has a plan, unlike the US

Pm's are not going up to their true value until during/ after the collapse. 

And China along with others will start that collapse, one way or the other.

Excellent short read that did not show up on mainstream.

At a special session of the Political Bureau of the Communist Party on Oct. 12 called to discuss the issue of global governance, President Xi Jinping called for a major reform of the system of global governance, reported Xinhua Tuesday. Reform is necessary in order for China to play a greater role in global governance, Xi said, and international organizations must reform in order to reflect the significance of emerging markets and developing countries. Reform is "an irresistible trend," Xi said, and reform at the global level is about "laying down rules for the international order and international mechanisms" as well as "deciding in which direction the world will head.

4 oz · Oct 19, 2015 - 11:42am

unchecked criminality & unending bullshit regulation

Going right along with all the unchecked criminality is the unending bullshit regulation that in every industry is being shoved down the throats of people who do still work by over site agencies (And peeps that somehow have to justify having their job.)

Is there any wonder the Labor Participation Rate is so low? 

Chris Brooks's photo.

lund175 · Oct 19, 2015 - 11:49am

Good Denver Dave article

Forewarned is forearmed: If you have the ability to cash out of your 401-K plan, you should do so now or be prepared to suffer the consequences of the most corrupted Ponzi scheme in financial market history (notwithstanding the U.S. Treasury debt scheme)

It’s been my belief that one of the primary reasons the Fed is propping up the stock market is to prevent a complete catastrophe in the nation’s pension system – both public and private. The culprit is underfunding. The underfunded of status of every single State pension fund is highly visible. However, through the magic of GAAP accounting and widespread upper management corporate fraud, most private pension funds may be even more underfunded than State funds

lund175 · Oct 19, 2015 - 11:56am

If you need something to kill time

If you need something to kill time until Turd's podcast, this is pushing 2 hours.

My friends and colleagues, Eric Dubin of The News Doctors and Jason Burack of Wall St. For Main St. have produced a discussion in their “Dystopia” series in which they discuss Glencore, China/yuan globalization, Deutsche Bank and several other topics affecting the markets currently and which the Fed/ECB/BoE are working furiously to paper over

Notice: If you do not see your new comment immediately, do not be alarmed. We are currently refreshing new comments approximately every 2 minutes to better manage performance while working on other issues. Thank you for your patience.

Become a gold member and subscribe to Turd's Vault


Donate  Shop

Get Your Subscriber Benefits

Exclusive discount for silver purchases, and a private iTunes feed for TF Metals Report podcasts!

Key Economic Events week of 12/10

12/11 8:30 ET Producer Price Index
12/12 8:30 ET Consumer Price Index
12/13 8:30 ET Import Price Index
12/14 8:30 ET Retail Sales
12/14 9:15 ET Industrial Prod. and Cap. Utilization
12/14 10:00 ET Business Inventories

Key Economic Events week of 11/26

11/27 9:00 ET Case-Schiller home prices
11/27 10:00 ET Consumer Confidence
11/28 8:30 ET Q3 GDP 2nd guess
11/28 10:00 ET New home sales
11/29 8:30 ET Personal Income and Spending
11/29 10:00 ET Pending home sales
11/29 2:00 ET November FOMC minutes

Key Economic Events week of 11/19

11/20 8:30 ET Housing Starts
11/21 8:30 ET Durable Goods
11/21 10:00 ET UMich Sentiment
11/21 10:00 ET LEIII
11/21 10:00 ET Existing Home Sales

Recent Comments