The Paper Armageddon Portfolio, One Year Later

Fri, Aug 29, 2014 - 2:53pm

As some of you may recall, I published an article here at TFMR one year ago in August of 2013 titled The Paper Armageddon Portfolio. In this piece I outlined a rationale for investing in certain sectors from a “hard assets/tangible value” perspective that would reflect the TFMR understanding of the ongoing Keynesian process of QE, artificially low interest rates, market manipulation, and dollar devaluation. Within those sectors, I selected multiple stocks from companies I felt would outperform the sector as a whole. The general idea was to come up with a list of companies who were poised to not only survive the current debt creation/paper ponzi economy, but would potentially offer solid returns in the coming paradigm where tangible and productive assets will be worth far more than today’s paper promises. So one year later I thought it would be worthwhile to check back in on this investing thesis to see how these picks and sectors fared and to discuss what we might learn from their performance over the last year.

The article I originally posted is here, but to summarize, I outlined four sectors oriented around hard assets and/or the real-world production of tangible goods. The four I chose were 1. Farmland, 2. Timber and grazing, 3. Energy and commodities, and 4. Railroads (which I surmised would be poised to grow in a high fuel costs/post-Petrodollar environment, and to take market share from the currently dominant but fuel inefficient trucking industry).

Let’s assume that, as I recommended in the article, Turdites looked at this list and spent a few weeks doing their own research and due diligence on these companies, then chose to invest a few weeks later. Here is a breakdown of the 1 year performance of these individual stocks I chose within these sectors in my original list. Each entry shows ticker symbol, price change over the last year, % gain, dividend yield, then what a $10,000 investment in that stock would be worth today, and finally how much dividend one would have been paid:


Ticker Price change % gain Div% Current value + Div.

CRESY- 8.00 to 11.62 (+45%) Div 2.9% --- 10k invested = $14,500, +290

SCPZF- 2.65 to 3.03 (+14.3%) Div 0% --- 10k= 11,430

LAND- 16.26 to 12.31, (-24.2%) Div 3% --- 10k=7,580, + 300

Timber and Grazing:

TPL- 85.76 to 200, (+133.2%) Div 0.2% --- 10k = 23,320 + 200

PCH- 38.56 to 42.70, (+10.7%) Div 3.4% --- 10k = 11,070, +340

PCL- 43.7 to 40.91, (-6.3%) Div 4.3% --- 10k = 9,370 +430


DBC- 26.74 to 24.96, ( – 6.6%) Div 0% --- 10k = 9,400

WHZ- 12.87 to 12.12, (-5.9%) Div 20.5% --- 10k = 9,410, +2,050

SDR- 13.5 to 6.7, (-50.3%) Div 24.4% --- 10k = 4,970 +2,440


CP- 82.5 to 200.46,(+142.9%) Div 0.7% --- 10k = 24,290 + 70

GWR- 86.5 to 98.01, ((+13.3%) Div 0% --- 10k = 11,330

NSC- 72.16 to 106.75, (+47.9%) Div 2.2% --- 10k = 14,790 +220

Total: Hypothetical $120,000 invested (10k each stock), 1yr total ROI =31.5%, now worth $157,800 (current stock value + Div)

Not too shabby- a healthy 31.5% gain for the year strongly outpaced the S&P just for the original list. But the hive-mind of Turdville is far smarter than any of us are by ourselves, and one of the things I asked in the original article was for Turdites to examine and comment on these companies and make suggestions they thought would be helpful for the list. During this discussion, Turdites noted that there were serious concerns or problems with three of the companies I listed, and I found their rationale for avoiding these companies to be both well informed, and quite persuasive. I noted this in the comments section, and based on my fellow Turdites critique, I excluded three of these companies from this list ( LAND, WHZ and SDR) in my own investments.

Not surprisingly, the brilliant folks here had smelled the stinkers and these companies wound up being dogs over the last year. By dropping these as the comments section suggested, the returns on the final “Turdite informed” portfolio were really quite something: For a hypothetical 90,000 invested, (10k each stock), 1yr total ROI = 56.25%, now worth $140,630 (current stock value + div).

So the picks within this investment thesis, run through the filter of the razor-sharp Turdville comments section, produced a 1 year gain of 56.25%. Boom, bitchez!

. . .

So what can we take away from all this? Well, I would suggest a couple of things but as usual, the best conclusions will be found in the comments section here, and I would encourage all of you to offer your impressions of what we might learn. For me, this is what I take away from this exercise:

1. Big money believes in the overall Turdville hard assets investment thesis

We don’t hear much about this on MSNBC (big shocker, right?) but these returns so far outpace the broader indexes that I suspect we are seeing big money trying to quietly build positions in companies that either own physical assets (like timber or grazing lands) or are positioned to thrive in a high energy costs environment (railroads). For decades now, financials have been the place to be for big money, but that is not where money is flowing over the last year- this list kicked butt over any financial sector index fund you can find. So one takeaway is that, although the hard assets investing community in general is still given the “tinfoil hat” treatment publicly in mainstream financial commentary, large money flows tell us that more and more deep pockets are quietly coming around to our way of thinking. They are positioning themselves for what we have seen coming for years now, but this movement is still not talked about much… yet. If one were cynical, one might think that big money would not allow the press to inform John Q Public about this until big money was already positioned for the ride. And we are nothing if not cynical!

2. Gold and Silver prices have yet to reflect these trends

No surprise to anyone here, but gold and silver should be doing extremely well in this environment and are vastly undervalued at current prices. The broader trends are confirming the overall investment thesis of TFMR- that the Keynesian debt creation economy has only one path it can follow and that path will eventually lead to a harsh revaluation downwards of all paper and paper based valuations. In short, we are in the process of leaving the world where paper ,debt, and Fed-driven fictional valuations are king, and are slowly entering a new paradigm where tangible and/or productive assets will rise to the top of the heap. The gains for the companies on my list reflect this. Gold and silver should be reflecting this, but aren’t… yet. For now, the monetary metals are the bargain-basement, blue-light special of the decade, and maybe the century. Stack ‘em up.

3. Why are hard assets/companies rising but the metals aren’t? The “M” word.

I am sure certain traders (especially those who rhyme with “pan”) will harf-up a hairball at hearing this, but I think the performance of this hard-asset portfolio over the last year, in contrast to what gold and silver have done, can be seen in a broader context as more evidence of the dreaded “M” word- manipulation. I posted on this a few months ago, but we all know that in normal times, gold acts the "thermometer of money creation", and both for its intrinsic value and as a hedge against the financial repression of artificially low interest rates, gold usually keeps pace or even outpaces currency devaluation. And yet, ever since the massive attack of September 2011 starting on the day of the Swiss Franc devaluation announcement, it has not. But it occurred to me that if the price of gold is being gamed (as it surely is) maybe we could find another proxy-measure that would show this... something that acts like gold would act, if gold were not so heavily manipulated.

I realized that farmland would share many qualities with gold and could be an excellent comparison. Like gold, farmland is a long-term store of value, and because it produces a crop it also has intrinsic value. Sales data are available, and it is so widely traded on such an individual basis (there are no effective institutions that can control or manipulate its price) that farmland might well act quite similarly to how gold would act... if gold were allowed to trade freely.

So I found a reliable dataset (the Iowa Farmland Value Survey) and charted the results against gold. The black line chart shows average farmland price per acre, for each year for the last ten years, against the weekly gold chart for the last decade:

The price of farmland tracked the price of gold incredibly closely year over year... right up until the famous attack on gold and silver in September of 2011. Since then, farmland has continued to rise but gold and silver have clearly been successfully shoved to the downside. To me, this chart shows quite plainly that the scale and intensity of PM manipulation was ratcheted up considerably starting at that time (as many of us who have followed these markets have sensed) and that it was successful in "breaking the relationship" between Fed-induced financial repression and gold price, at least for now. They were not able to do the same to farmland prices, however, and the continuing rise clearly reflects the ongoing process of currency devaluation. In short, farmland is doing what gold is supposed to do in a freely-traded market, presumably because gold (through paper manipulation) is easily controlled, while farmland sales and prices are not.

This also suggests to me that the snap-back for gold and silver could be quite something.

4. Even for tangible asset companies, current prices are high… so I’ll wait

I have to be honest, I could not bring myself to buy these companies today- the valuations are just too dang high! I noted in my article what a great company I thought Canadian Pacific is, but there is no way I’m paying 200 bucks per share for that sucker. The same goes for most of these companies. I may be wrong on this, but the entire market is so overvalued that I cannot in good conscience buy anything at these levels, so there will be no Paper Armageddon Portfolio II. What I will do, however, is to wait in the tall grass and bide my time. I believe this market is poised for a major correction and whether it happens in six weeks or in sixty, I want to have cash on the sidelines and be ready to invest, based on the hard assets thesis and working from this list of sectors. My personal plan is to begin to average in, but only starting after we see a +20% correction in the overall market then slowly average into positions for the long term, knowing full well that a correction could go as deep as 50% or more and that my early investments may be losers for a time. Obviously, we will need to be on our toes and be strongly invested in metals, tangibles, etc. in the mean-time, because there is no telling what may happen once the Fed’s carefully balanced perpetual dollar debt machine starts spitting gears. Nonetheless, for now cash is king and metals are a must. Keep ‘em handy and be ready to deploy both, when bargains arise and opportunity presents itself!

5. Get the stock certificates in-hand… Turdite Nick Elway shows you how

At the end of the comments in the original article, longtime Turdite Nick Elway posed a series of outstanding comments and instructions on how to actually obtain the stock certificates for shares you own. His posts unfortunately got buried at the end of the thread, but should be MUST READING for Turdites. Rather than having your broker “owe” you the stocks, you can separate your ownership of these companies from the middle man (who might be, and likely is, a bankrupt institution that you do not want to rely on if the financial SHTF).

Nick’s comments start here ( and continue down the page. Copy and print them out, because this is excellent information. Thank you Nick- you da man!!!

Stay frosty out there.

About the Author


Aug 29, 2014 - 2:58pm


Thanks for your scholarship!

F. Capra

Aug 29, 2014 - 3:09pm

Pining 4 . . . thanks for even more proof. . .

that we are still right--just early.

Aug 29, 2014 - 3:20pm

Thats outstanding

Thank you, Pining!

(Maybe we should start a TFMR Hedge Fund?)

Aug 29, 2014 - 3:28pm

Since this is a public

Since this is a public thread, I want to strongly encourage EVERYONE to read this, particularly the naysayers who always show up to badmouth gold and try to convince everyone to sell.

Aug 29, 2014 - 3:30pm


Just signed up with Jim Comiskey. Mentioned your name. Bought some oil futures. Will be buying grains soon.

Aug 29, 2014 - 3:38pm

He's a good man

And he works his ass off. His partner Teddy is always available, too.

(Full disclosure: I receive no compensation in this case and I'm not a "referring broker", though Jim will freely admit that he owes me quite a few beers for all of the business I've sent him over the past few years...)

Aug 29, 2014 - 4:20pm

For Those Short The Metals

Most of us remember to the day and hour a date coming up.

“A review of ISIS social media messaging during the week ending August 26 shows that militants are expressing an increased interest in the notion that they could clandestinely infiltrate the southwest border of US, for terror attack,” warns the Texas Department of Public Safety "situational awareness" bulletin, obtained by

transplanted baby
Aug 29, 2014 - 4:22pm

wonderful returns

but has anyone forgot that those returns are in Fed notes- the thing we rail against. And so what if we make a great return. It only means that our country is in debt to the amount of our return. And the FED is going to print more money so that we can see a greater numerical return. And that manipulation is going to weaken the dollar as a reserve currency and that is going to lead to hyperinflation in the US. Really, weren't we against these shenanigans?
Nonetheless, Pining your article was a nice read.

Aug 29, 2014 - 4:29pm

Very good article

I will be sending this to some collegues in the investment business in Canada. Somtimes an expert is someone from out of town.


So It Goes
Aug 29, 2014 - 4:49pm

@ Pining

Very informative review - much appreciated. IMO, you demonstrate very clearly that the precious metals are acting in a very bizarre beaten down way when compared to other REAL things. I too believe the precious metals are a screaming buy right now.

My concern about your investing thesis is the underlying assumption that we will NOT have a currency collapse.

I do not see any alternative to the US dollar collapsing in value. In fact, the reserve status that the dollar has enjoyed is currently ending. I don't pretend to know when the collapse will occur. I don't pretend to know its shape or form. I don't pretend to know whether the collapse will incremental or sudden. So, I don't pretend to know how the collapse will play out.

But, why hold any cash now? If you hold physical gold (silver) outside of the banking system, it is only a quick transaction to either convert the precious metal back to cash or to trade it for the asset that you want to buy.

Precious metals will never go to zero while paper dollars may rapidly go toward zero value. If that were the case, what is the good of holding stock certificates, even if they are in your name? The government could, in its wisdom [sarc] decide to confiscate paper (which would be much easier than confiscating physical precious metals).

I guess my post could be summarized: what will any paper be worth if the future of paper is so unpredictable?

Thanks again for your insights.

Key Economic Events Week of 2/24

2/25 9:00 ET Case-Shiller home prices
2/26 10:00 ET New home sales
2/27 8:30 ET Q4 GDP second guess
2/27 8:30 ET Durable Goods
2/27 11:30 ET Goon Evans speech
2/28 8:30 ET Pers Income and Spending
2/28 8:30 ET Core Inflation
2/28 9:45 ET Chicago PMI

Subscribe or login to read all comments.


Donate Shop

Get Your Subscriber Benefits

Private iTunes feed for all TF Metals Report podcasts, and access to Vault member forum discussions!

Key Economic Events Week of 2/24

2/25 9:00 ET Case-Shiller home prices
2/26 10:00 ET New home sales
2/27 8:30 ET Q4 GDP second guess
2/27 8:30 ET Durable Goods
2/27 11:30 ET Goon Evans speech
2/28 8:30 ET Pers Income and Spending
2/28 8:30 ET Core Inflation
2/28 9:45 ET Chicago PMI

Key Economic Events Week of 2/17

2/18 8:30 ET Empire St Manu Idx
2/19 8:30 ET Producer Price Idx
2/19 8:30 ET Housing Starts & Bldg Perms
2/19 2:00 ET January FOMC minutes
2/20 8:30 ET Philly Fed
2/21 Fed Goons all day at Chicago Conf.
2/21 9:45 ET Markit flash Feb PMIs

Key Economic Events Week of 2/10

2/11 10:00 ET Job Openings
2/11 10:00 ET CGP Hump-Hawk House
2/12 10:00 ET CGP Hump-Hawk Senate
2/13 8:30 ET CPI
2/14 8:30 ET Retail Sales
2/14 9:15 ET Cap Ute & Ind Prod
2/14 10:00 ET Business Inventories

Key Economic Events Week of 2/3

2/4 10:00 ET Factory Orders
2/5 8:15 ET ADP Employment
2/5 9:45 ET Markit Service PMI
2/5 10:00 ET ISM Service PMI
2/6 8:30 ET Productivity & Unit Labor Costs
2/7 8:30 ET BLSBS
2/7 10:00 ET Wholesale Inventories

Key Economic Events Week of 1/27

1/28 8:30 ET Durable Goods
1/28 10:00 ET Consumer Confidence
1/29 10:00 ET Pending Home Sales
1/29 2:00 pm ET FOMC Fedlines
1/29 2:30 pm ET Powell presser
1/30 8:30 ET Q4 GDP first guess
1/31 8:30 ET Pers Inc and Spending
1/31 9:45 ET Chicago PMI
2/2 10:00 pm ET Chiefs win SB LIV

Key Economic Events Week of 1/13

1/14 8:30 ET CPI
1/14 9:00 ET Goon Williams
1/15 8:30 ET PPI and Empire Fed
1/16 8:30 ET Retail Sales and Philly Fed
1/17 8:30 ET Housing Starts
1/17 9:15 Et Cap Ute and Ind Prod

Key Economic Events Week of 1/6

1/7 8:30 ET US trade deficit
1/7 10:00 ET ISM Services PMI
1/7 10:00 ET Factory Orders
1/8 8:15 ET ADP employment
1/9 8:00 ET Goon Chlamydia speech
1/9 1:20 ET Goon Evans 2:00 ET Goon Bullard
1/10 8:30 ET BLSBS
1/10 10:00 ET Wholesale Inventories

Key Economic Events Week of 12/16

12/16 8:30 ET Empire State Manu Idx
12/16 9:45 ET Markit flash PMIs Dec
12/17 8:30 ET Housing Starts and Bldg Perms
12/17 9:15 ET Cap Ute and Ind Prod
12/19 8:30 ET Philly Fed
12/20 8:30 ET Final guess Q3 GDP
12/20 10:00 ET Pers Inc and Spending
12/20 10:00 ET Core Inflation

Key Economic Events Week of 12/9

12/10 8:30 ET Productivity and Unit Labor Costs
12/11 8:30 ET CPI
12/11 2:00 pm ET FOMC fedlines
12/11 2:30 pm ET CGP presser
12/12 8:30 ET PPI
12/13 8:30 ET Retail Sales
12/13 10:00 ET Business Inventories
12/13 11:00 ET Goon Williams speech

Key Economic Events Week of 12/2

12/2 9:45 ET Markit Manu PMI
12/2 10:00 ET ISM Manu PMI
12/2 10:00 ET Construction Spending
12/4 9:45 ET Markit Services PMI
12/4 10:00 ET ISM Services PMI
12/5 8:30 ET Trade Deficit
12/5 10:00 ET Factory Orders
12/6 8:30 ET BLSBS
12/6 10:00 ET Wholesale Inventories

Forum Discussion

by Green Lantern, 4 hours 31 min ago
by silverseeker, 4 hours 36 min ago
by mavens, 5 hours 38 min ago
by waxybilldupp, 6 hours 25 min ago