Turd in Backwardation

Wed, May 9, 2012 - 1:08pm

That just sounds painful, doesn't it? Yikes! However, as the title suggests, I am personally in backwardation today as I feel the best way to summarize our current position is to give you my conclusion first and then work backwards from there.

Conclusion: The days of outright Bullion Bank (Cartel) manipulation and suppression of precious metal prices are drawing to a close. By later this year and perhaps as soon as late this summer, The Cartels (particularly silver) will have flattened their books to the point where the metals will finally be allowed to trade toward a price that truly reflects an equilibrium between investor demand and physical supply.

I believe that what we are currently experiencing are the final stages of this "book-flattening" process. In silver, the process began in April of 2011 when a sudden supply squeeze nearly created a commercial signal failure. Stopping there, you should click this link right now and read the entire post linked below:


The one thing the Bankers are NOT is stupid. They KNOW that if they continue down the silver manipulation highway, it is only a matter of time before the situation of Spring 2011 repeats itself. I believe that everything that has happened in silver since 4/29/11 has been for the ultimate purpose of getting out from under this position. Though there have been spikes like last February where the EE short position expanded, these moves were only undertaken to squash and control price until the Silver Cartel is finally ready. To effectively cover and exit the market is a painstaking process that requires time. The good news is: Time is almost up.

The Gold Cartel had a similar, life-altering experience in August of last year after the S&P downgrade of U.S. debt. While the stock market fell, gold soared to all-time highs on the backs of near-frantic short-covering by The Cartel. By Labor Day weekend, the pain was immense and, with news pending that the Swiss were about to devalue the Franc by 10%, dramatic action was demanded. Today's market is still reflecting that 9/5/11 decision.

Just as TARP was a transference of risk from the banks to the general public, the current trend in the metals is allowing the Bullion Banks to transfer their short positions from themselves to the speculators. Seemingly all of the new open interest is coming from new spec short positions being opened and who is on the other (buying) side of those trades, The Cartel of course! Not every trade, mind you, but enough of the trades to make a serious dent in their overall, net short position. Therefore, we must expect this process to continue. Gold may never reach a 1:1 parity of the Cartel net short position but I believe silver will...and soon.

Why, you ask? Because silver is deadly. It truly is the "silver bullet" for the vampires that have suppressed price for decades. Industrial and monetary demand has created a consistent shortfall in availability, as illustrated below by Casey Research:

Looking at this chart, do you see why price has risen from $4 t0 $30? Given that physical demand will only increase as fiat currency is devalued, we can rightly expect price to increase, as well. Throw in the ongoing CFTC investigation, the increased awareness of manipulation, the multiple, price-rigging lawsuits and the impending open of "Ned & Andy's Allocated Silver Exchange" in China and you get an environment that any sensible banker would love to exit...and they are doing just that.

All that said, I would expect lower lows before this is over. Yes, sovereign and central bank physical demand is strong but, in an environment where "the tail continues to wag the dog", price can still head lower. There is considerable headline and liquidity risk here and it will be quite easy for The Silver Cartel to induce more shorting into which they can cover. While it is entirely possible that silver is "compressing the spring" here and will not trade lower than today's lows, I think instead there's a higher probability that the situation in Europe spins out of control. This causes a flight to the dollar and liquidity crush which drives silver to $26 and, if the considerable shorts below $26 can get gunned, maybe even $22-23.

Now, I'm sure that you didn't like reading that any more than I like typing it but it is what it is. If I'm right about JPM et al exiting once and for all their silver short position, it may take a washout of this magnitude to pull it off. HOWEVER, THERE IS VERY GOOD NEWS HERE! If this plays out, you must hold your nose, avert your eyes and buy with both hands. With the manipulation removed, silver will soar. Forty dollars. Fifty dollars, Eighty dollars per ounce. All of those levels will come into view. Those sturdy souls willing to hold AND add to positions here will be richly rewarded in peace of mind AND value.

As mentioned above, The Gold Cartel is going through a similar transition. The difference for them, though, is that I highly doubt they will ever be net long. The Fed, the ECB and the BoE will continue to demand that gold's ascent be managed. That said, rapidly increasing monetary demand makes the net short positions to which we've all become accustomed suicidal. And, as we know from 2008, the TBTF banks must be preserved at all costs. Therefore, gold must be allowed higher but The Cartel must still attempt to control it without catastrophic collapse. The only alternative is for The Gold Cartel top remain in the gold market but a much less visible level. Last week's CoT showed a net short ratio of 2.16:1. This is down from 2.68:1 in late February and 2.86:1 last July. Again, I don't expect that we'll ever see 1:1 but I do think that the ratio is headed well below 2:1. What type of paper price action would bring about this change in the net short ratio? How about a drop to 1525? Maybe the gold sell stops get gunned, too, during a global liquidity crisis and gold falls all the way to 1450? That ought to do it.

(By the way, note that I didn't write my thought onto the charts today. Two reasons: 1) To avoid influencing your opinion outside of the lines drawn and 2) to highlight the risk disclaimer RJO places on every page.)

Anyway, I've been at this all morning so I'm going to stop here. But, first, a couple of things:

  1. I see that price bounced and rebounded as expected off of 1580. It made it all the way back to near 1600 before getting beaten back. Silver rallied off of 28.60 to near 29.40 before being hammered back. I would advise you against chasing here. Once the trend changes...and it will, eventually...there will be plenty of time to get long. For now, unless you are part of Turd's Army, stay out of the way.
  2. Please don't go off from here and cite this post without providing context. I hope I don't read somewhere that "the hypocrite Turd Ferguson now says gold is going to 1450". I'm doing my best to keep you informed and a part of that effort is a willingness to accept the situation for what it is. IF we see gold plummet to $1450 and silver at $22, it will only be for a brief moment in time and it will signal your opportunity of a lifetime to get (and stay) long.
  3. The miners probably aren't done going down, either. As you might imagine, in a renewed global liquidity crisis, all equities will be declining along with the miners. At a 350 HUI, though, even I'll be tempted to finally jump back into the pool.

So, please, hang in there. The next, few weeks and months are likely going to be painfully challenging and the atmosphere in Turdville my become downright toxic. Don't let it get you down. I'm convinced that we are in the final stages of this ruthless, Cartel-position-shifting "correction". Once this is completed, the rallies from the lows will be breathtaking. Keep the faith. Use the continued weakness to add to your stacks. Live your life with joy and be happy.


About the Author

turd [at] tfmetalsreport [dot] com ()


May 9, 2012 - 1:11pm


I said I wouldn't do it again..

May 9, 2012 - 1:12pm

I should add

I asked Ned this morning about this story going around that the PAGE is going to be opening in June. He says this is complete nonsense. PAGE is dead and gone.

We still hope to see "Ned & Andy's Allocated Silver Exchange" very soon, however.

Chi-Town Deadhead
May 9, 2012 - 1:12pm


Thurd - wow first time in top three.

Keep Stacking.

May 9, 2012 - 1:13pm

The Demonetization of Silver an Act of Genocide Against Slvfish!

History is just that: HIS-STORY. It is a play conjured by entrenched interests who have time and history on their side. The macro-events of daily life are not the effect of democratic processes or chance, but, instead, the execution of all things by powers-that-be, with 24 hour think-tanks and the bloodline of civilization, rule of money, to their advantage.

The demonetization of silver paralleled a time in United States history of deep wealth re-allocation. Powerful interests with the support of international power brokers managed to restructure the landscape of the U.S economy and its politics. Forty years after demonetization, the Federal Reserve was set up and the First World War was beginning.

Power plays like demonetization of silver happen swiftly and can leave lasting effects over decades and centuries. With one decree, the course of the future can be forever remapped and a new world can come into view. What happened to silver in 1873 is the same thing that is happening to the U.S Dollar, The Federal Reserve Note, in this, the twenty-first century.

Just as the so-called “silver fish” awoke one morning in 1873 without savings, so too will their progeny of today, one day wake up having saved in a money no longer money.

Silver Vigilante
May 9, 2012 - 1:16pm

Invoking John Maynard

The much-maligned Keynes opined that markets can stay irrational longer than an investor can remain solvent.

He wasn't speaking of manipulated markets, but I believe the thought still applies. We've read for a long time that the end of manipulation was near. Yet, it continues.

It must end sometime because of the inherent contradictions, but the wait could be longer than any of us could imagine.

And that gives pause during the course of this ongoing smackdown. Optimism is a wasting asset, in great need of support and reaffirmation -- hard evidence, not merely speculation.

So, we wait, and hope for better.

May 9, 2012 - 1:16pm

Not First !

Not First !

May 9, 2012 - 1:17pm

Still here

"I'm still here, you bastards!" Steve McQueen as Papillon - scene as Papillon curses the sky while on his back on a makeshift raft adrift in the middle of the Pacific.

May 9, 2012 - 1:18pm

stacker respective

from my lowly respective as a stacker,

with the USD in the 80.xx, and silver at 29.xx. im a buyer.

sure the usd may go up, but 80 is close enough to the top of its current "channel" for me. im getting rid of these funny notes while the dollar is up.

if silver goes lower, ill just buy more.

May 9, 2012 - 1:19pm

LCS Update

I’m still seeing very high premiums on all silver and gold, close to $8.00 over spot on ASE . And the LCS is doing way more selling of late then buying. The guy is almost out of all the good stuff, mostly junk left. I'm buying the hell out of it right now!!!

May 9, 2012 - 1:23pm

Spectator Sport

"Gee whiz, Mary- Look at how it just blew right through support there. Golly. That's something you don't see every day. Kids, have you ever heard the term "Child labor"? No? Well don't worry, you're going to learn about it real soon."

May 9, 2012 - 1:24pm

got a friend to buy for the first time yesterday...

Got a friend to buy their first physical silver yesterday...slowly but surely the sheeple are waking up...

May 9, 2012 - 1:25pm

David Einhorn and Ron Paul Tackle the Fed


"From the Great Depression to the Great Recession, financial panics and the Fed’s inability to prevent them are nothing new. As a result, Dr. Paul continues to advocate a changing of the guard. On Tuesday, he hosted a Congressional hearing on monetary policy and the Federal Reserve. The hearing was titled “The Federal Reserve System: Mend It Or End It?” and involved testimony from several economists and lawmakers. “More and more people are beginning to understand just how destructive the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy has been,” Paul said in a press release. “I hope that this hearing will kick start a serious discussion on the need to rein in the Fed.”

While few are expecting immediate action to be taken against the Fed, the columns by Einhorn and Dr. Paul raise public awareness and just might inspire individuals to consider ways to protect themselves against the damaging monetary policies implemented by the Fed. Einhorn and Dr. Paul both view gold and gold miners as one way to seek protection."

May 9, 2012 - 1:27pm

excerpt from Uncle Ted

He just released his midweek update a few minutes ago. Here's a paragraph:

"What can we do about this as investors, market participants and citizens? I can only speak for myself, but I am not selling silver here or lower. I don’t know how low we may go from here and there is nothing I can do to prevent a decline, so I’m not going to obsess over it. As new funds become available, I’ll buy more silver. I’m in it for the long run or until I see signs that silver is free of manipulation and exhibiting signs of overvaluation. That’s very far from the case presently. The COT structure was bullish before this last sell-off and is even more bullish now. Try to remember that the collusive COMEX commercials are buying, illegally in my opinion, but buying nevertheless. No one, not even a crook, buys anything that he doesn’t expect to rise in price. Certainly at past extremes of commercial buying, it invariably turned out to be a good time to buy. The key test will be if JPMorgan sells short additional contracts on the next meaningful silver rally. Although that rally may not feel close at hand, I can assure you that we will get it eventually and the answer to what JPMorgan will do. When the rally does come it should prove to be explosive if JPMorgan decides to quit manipulating the price."

May 9, 2012 - 1:29pm

What about today's action??

Dear Turd,

what about today's action??if this is short covering.....unemployment figure tomorrow..followed by Ben's speech tomorrow shouldn't we wait for the COT report??Do we smell somethig cooking..besides this..

Adding Insult To Injury, Goldman Cuts US Q1 GDP To 1.9%


May 9, 2012 - 1:29pm

Downside AG targets

Interesting that today both Nenner and Turd say that 23 is a potential downside target. Personally I am so far invested in phyzz that I am not tempted to add to the stack unless the price gets that low. The small amount of dry powder is to be kept until I can see the whites of the Cartel's eyes. If physical premiums do not come down, I'll hold onto the cash and finish the prepping.

We haven't seen anything really dramatic in Europe yet. Let's see what a major bank going down or a sovereign default does to the PMs.

I wish I was in Turd's position with the miners.

May 9, 2012 - 1:32pm

Hey Turd, do you think we can

Hey Turd, do you think we can get one more upleg in the miners and phys before a 2008 style liquidity crisis due to Europe?

Kuchek TF
May 9, 2012 - 1:33pm


Thanks, that was exactly the type of clarification I was looking for.

May 9, 2012 - 1:33pm


Never so close.16th.

Metals are going down,down...deeper and down. sq

May 9, 2012 - 1:34pm

Good analysis

I will certainly be one of those enjoying the next amazing rise.....and what I do with that rise is going to have to depend. If we have already seen QE3 by the time we see the next leg up, I will certainly not exchange anything for the metal. That's for sure.

May 9, 2012 - 1:39pm
May 9, 2012 - 1:40pm


I'm not sure about the timing here TF. Going by the news flow it sure seems that there will be a breakdown of sorts before the cartel is able to cover into a comfortable short position. I think that they sorely misjudged the ability of the public to figure out their multiple scams and frauds, and not just in the PM mkts.

No, I think if they're going to get flat they'll have to do it in a hurry and sooner than they thought because otherwise there will be a very serious societal breakdown due to the unprosecuted frauds and other criminal activity we all see on a daily basis.

Make no mistake, they will get flat. One way or the other.

May 9, 2012 - 1:42pm


HUI -Derived from Market data
As of May 09, 2012
Company Symbol Latest
Change Time High Low Volume 52 Weeks
Net % High Low
Agnico Eagle Mines Ltd NYSE:AEM 38.31 USD 37.29 +1.02 +2.74% 13:22 38.90 36.29 505181 73.07 31.45
Anglogold Ashanti Ltd NYSE:AU 32.96 USD 32.47 +0.49 +1.51% 13:21 33.05 31.85 585538 49.12 32.04
Barrick Gold Corp NYSE:ABX 38.09 USD 36.72 +1.37 +3.73% 13:21 38.29 35.62 1742128 55.94 36.20
Coeur D Alene Mines Corp NYSE:CDE 18.69 USD 18.46 +0.23 +1.25% 13:21 18.76 17.90 1508119 30.99 17.86
Compania de Minas Buenaventura NYSE:BVN 39.19 USD 39.43 -0.24 -0.61% 13:21 39.62 38.47 650451 49.45 35.33
Eldorado Gold Corp NYSE:EGO 12.18 USD 11.67 +0.51 +4.37% 13:21 12.22 11.29 971428 22.12 11.66
Gold Fields Ltd NYSE:GFI 12.97 USD 12.61 +0.36 +2.86% 13:21 12.98 12.36 464111 18.48 12.15
Goldcorp Inc NYSE:GG 35.82 USD 34.55 +1.27 +3.68% 13:21 35.90 33.56 1471146 56.31 34.14
Harmony Gold Mining Co Ltd AMEX:HMY 9.48 USD 9.16 +0.32 +3.49% 13:21 9.51 8.92 274619 15.10 8.99
Hecla Mining Co NYSE:HL 4.14 USD 4.10 +0.04 +0.98% 13:21 4.14 3.91 750828 8.82 3.79
Iamgold Corp NYSE:IAG 10.82 USD 10.87 -0.05 -0.46% 13:21 10.97 10.51 900023 23.87 10.71
Kinross Gold Corp NYSE:KGC 7.84 USD 7.78 +0.06 +0.77% 13:21 7.93 7.11 2819677 18.25 7.66
Newmont Mining Corp NYSE:NEM 47.03 USD 44.76 +2.27 +5.07% 13:21 47.03 43.95 1114488 72.41 44.22
Randgold Resources Ltd NASDAQNM:GOLD 78.71 USD 77.61 +1.10 +1.42% 13:20 79.28 75.82 762249 120.73 73.10
Yamana Gold Inc NYSE:AUY 13.90 USD 13.44 +0.46 +3.42% 13:21 13.93 13.01 1225065 18.16 11.11
HUI top5 -Derived from Market data
As of May 09, 2012
Company Symbol Latest
Change Time High Low Volume 52 Weeks
Net % High Low
Newmont Mining Corp NYSE:NEM 47.03 USD 44.76 +2.27 +5.07% 13:21 47.03 43.95 1114488 72.41 44.22
Eldorado Gold Corp NYSE:EGO 12.18 USD 11.67 +0.51 +4.37% 13:21 12.22 11.29 971428 22.12 11.66
Barrick Gold Corp NYSE:ABX 38.09 USD 36.72 +1.37 +3.73% 13:21 38.29 35.62 1742128 55.94 36.20
Goldcorp Inc NYSE:GG 35.82 USD 34.55 +1.27 +3.68% 13:21 35.90 33.56 1471146 56.31 34.14
Harmony Gold Mining Co Ltd AMEX:HMY 9.48 USD 9.16 +0.32 +3.49% 13:21 9.51 8.92 274619 15.10 8.99
May 9, 2012 - 1:49pm

I need some support.

Does any one have any info on..........

Almaden Minerals Ltd


Or an opinion on taking a long position?

Yesterday, I bought 5000 shares@ $1.88.

Should I get out NOW!

May 9, 2012 - 1:51pm

Good post Turd

makes sense

May 9, 2012 - 1:55pm

The Fundamentals Say ~ Same, Same.

Watching this slowly unfolding, ongoing pricing games, will eventually drive you wacky!

Focus your attention on the long picture and the macro, global outlook instead. What do they say?

To me they say SNAFU! (SITUATION NORMAL ALL F*****D UP) Still!

There has been NO economic improvement, either micro or macro, that will change the direction of the global debt Ponzi scheme from imploding of it's own sheer weight. The only answer the CB's have is more printing and currency debasement in an attempt to inflate the debt away.

Unfortunately, this will cause untold misery and pain to those that can least afford it ~ the poor, who will see their savings and pensions inflated away to nothing. While those who are right and sit tight, with their wealth protected by holding physical gold and silver, will come out the other side relatively intact.

What a great buying opportunity at these cheap prices, before the paper you are holding gets devalued to worthlessness.

May 9, 2012 - 1:56pm

RE:- Turd in Backwardation

Here you go ... A practical demonstration of a "Turd in Backwardation" at 5:45 mins in :-

Video unavailable
May 9, 2012 - 1:59pm

I'm 28 and stack all I can

I'm 28 and stack all I can when I can. Silver can go to $0 and I still won't sell. Why? Because the whole system is evil and corrupt and I'd rather have my money in and old, dirty industrial metal than in FRN's - even if it means being destitute. I'd rather be poor and have my silver, than be rich and have all the FRN's in the world. Bernanke can keep them.

May 9, 2012 - 2:01pm

Sprott CNBC Fast Money

Someone was asking for the CNBC Sprott interview link in the last thread:


York Rite
May 9, 2012 - 2:02pm
May 9, 2012 - 2:02pm

Time for daily dose of doomporn..

Preparing For Massive Civil War, Re-Education Camps https://www.rense.com/general95/camps_dev.html


Donate Shop

Get Your Subscriber Benefits

Exclusive discount for silver purchases, and a private iTunes feed for TF Metals Report podcasts!

Key Economic Events Week of 5/20

5/20 7:00 pm ET CGP speech
5/21 10:00 ET Existing Home Sales
5/22 2:00 ET FOMC minutes
5/23 9:45 ET Markit PMIs
5/24 8:30 ET Durable Goods

Key Economic Events Week of 5/13

TWELVE Goon speeches through the week
5/14 8:30 ET Import Price Index
5/15 8:30 ET Retail Sales and Empire State Manu. Idx.
5/15 9:15 ET Cap. Ute. and Ind. Prod.
5/15 10:00 ET Business Inventories
5/16 10:00 ET Housing Starts and Philly Fed
5/17 10:00 ET Consumer Sentiment

Key Economic Events Week of 5/6

5/9 8:30 ET US Trade Deficit
5/9 8:30 ET Producer Price Index (PPI)
5/9 10:00 ET Wholesale Inventories
5/10 8:30 ET Consumer Price Index (CPI)

Recent Comments

by Libero, 4 min 3 sec ago
by AGAU, 6 min 10 sec ago
by Turd Ferguson, 45 min 5 sec ago
by Turd Ferguson, 45 min 39 sec ago
by Green Lantern, 2 hours 30 min ago
by Harley, 7 hours 28 min ago