It Has To Be Said, So I'll Say It

Thu, Aug 4, 2011 - 10:01pm

The U.S stock market now off over 10% in the past three weeks. Pundits and analysts are panting and scratching their heads, searching for the root causes. The typical "news" story goes something like this, from the WSJ:

"There was no one single catalyst for the downdraft, traders said. Rather it reflected multiple concerns that have mounted over the past month and came to a head this week. Worries about a U.S. default, settled by a last-minute fix to lift the country's debt limit on Tuesday, have given way to broader fears about the failing health of the domestic economy. That will lead to close scrutiny of Friday's jobs report. In Europe, leaders are grappling with a widening debt crisis, which started in Greece and spread to Italy and Spain. An earlier bailout of Greece now appears insufficient. There are growing concerns about European banks and their heavy investments in the debt of countries with big fiscal problems. The Dow's decline was its biggest point drop since the market was plunging amid a crisis of confidence in banks in late 2008. On Thursday, the focus has shifted to world governments, which are laboring under mountains of debt and have diminished ability to prop up the financial system."

But financial writers and television talking heads rarely possess the wisdom and experience necessary to see through the "fog of war". Most just stick to the status quo and read the copy that is given to them. If they took the time to think critically, they might not simply glance over this, from Reuters:

"Thu Aug 4, 2011 4:31pm EDT

* Safe-haven bid sends 10-yr Treas yields below 2.5 pct
* Two-year note yields fall to record low 0.27 pct
* Major U.S. stock indexes down about 4.5 percent

By Chris Reese
NEW YORK, Aug 4 (Reuters) - U.S. Treasury debt prices
soared on Thursday as recession fears cued investors to flee
riskier assets like stocks and seek safety in U.S. government
Major U.S. stock .SPX.IXIC.DJI indexes plunged about
4.5 percent and the U.S. bond market was on track for its
sharpest week-long drop in yields since the height of the
global financial crisis.
"The market is beset by uncertainty and fear," said Milton
Ezrati, market strategist at Lord Abbett & Co in Jersey City,
New Jersey, adding "there are a lot of worries about the
economy. The double-dip fears are more real now than last year
-- people are throwing in the towel because they can't find
relief on any front."
The safety buying straddled the Treasury curve, with
Treasury bill rates trading in negative territory, two-year
note yields falling to record lows and longer-dated yields
dipping to the lowest in nearly 10 months.
Bank of New York Mellon Corp (BK.N) said it was being so
overwhelmed with deposits from investors fleeing risky markets
that it will begin charging for above-average deposits. Some
traders said this added to the downward pressure on T-bill
rates as investors looked for a place to stash their cash. For
details, see [ID:nN1E7730Y0]
Benchmark 10-year Treasury notes US10YT=RR traded 1-24/32
higher in price to yield 2.42 percent, the lowest since
mid-October and down from 2.63 percent late on Wednesday.
Benchmark yields are set for the biggest six-day fall since
December, 2008, and have shed over half a percentage point in
the last week alone.

Hmmm. What a curious development this is. The global level of fear is now so high that T-bill rates have turned negative, just like they did in 2008. Investors and money managers are so fearful, they are paying the U.S. government to take their money from them. Again, hmmm.

OK the above, by itself, is not that unusual. However, what if I next give you this, straight from the press release on Monday, issued by the U.S. Treasury Department:

"Treasury Announces Marketable Borrowing Estimates

WASHINGTON - The U.S. Department of the Treasury today announced its current estimates of net marketable borrowing for the July – September 2011 and the October – December 2011 quarters:

During the July – September 2011 quarter, Treasury expects to issue $331 billion in net marketable debt, assuming an end-of-September cash balance of $110 billion. This borrowing estimate is $74 billion lower than announced in May 2011. The decrease in borrowing largely relates to lower outlays and cash balance adjustments.
During the October – December 2011 quarter, Treasury expects to issue $285 billion in net marketable debt, assuming an end-of-December cash balance of $100 billion.
During the April - June 2011 quarter, Treasury issued $190 billion in net marketable debt, and ended the quarter with a cash balance of $137 billion, of which $5 billion was attributable to the Supplementary Financing Program (SFP). In May 2011, Treasury estimated $142 billion in net marketable borrowing and assumed an end-of-June cash balance of $95 billion, which included an SFP balance of $5 billion.

Additional financing details relating to Treasury’s Quarterly Refunding will be released at 9:00 a.m. on Wednesday, August 3, 2011."

And then I followed it up with this commentary from Zero Hedge:

"Tim Geithner has released his projection of expected borrowing needs for the final fiscal quarter of 2011 (ending on September 30). But before that, we learn that while back on May 1 the Treasury had expected to raise $142 billion in marketable debt in Q3, instead if raised $190 billion, with the difference going primarily to build up the EOQ cash balance which instead of being $95 billion, was $137 billion, obviously due to the threat of the debt ceiling breach. That threat however has not prevented the Treasury from assuming that the debt ceiling will be raised without a hitch, and it now predicts issuing $331 billion in net marketable debt issued in Q4, $74 billion less than the projection from May 1 (and further sees another $285 billion in borrowing needs in Q1 2012). In other words, if there is no debt ceiling deal, the Treasury will be $616 billion short in revenues over the next 6 months. Of course, the numbers net out the massive issuance that has to hit the market to fund the "disinvested" government retirement funds and various other mechanism that were used to prevent the Treasury from running out of cash, which amount to about $300 billion primarily in the form of short-term bills that matured and were not rolled over to make space for marketable debt issuance. In other words, gross issuance in the next quarter will be about over $660 billion. This is just a little under the total debt issued in the last 3 quarters (due to the May 16th debt ceiling breach)! And people think the Treasury can raise this money without the Fed monetizing at will? Fascinating."

Now we're getting somewhere. All of this led me to recall the first item I ever saw published by "Tyler Durden". Published on the day after Christmas in 2009, Tyler speculated on the source for U.S. government funding in 2010. A link to the entire post is below but here is a c&p of his main thesis:

"What options does this leave for the administration? Very few, and all of them are ugly. As we stated earlier on, the options for the Fed are threefold:

1) Announce a new iteration of Quantitative Easing. This will be met with major disapproval across all voting classes (at least those whose residential zip codes do not start with 10xxx or 068xx), creating major headaches for Obama and the democrats which are already struggling with collapsing polls.
2) Prepare for a major increase in interest rates. While on the surface this would be very welcome for a Fed that keeps hinting that deflation is the biggest concern for the economy, Bernanke's complete lack of preparation from a monetary standpoint (we are surprised the Fed's $200 million reverse repos have not made the late night comedy circuit yet) to a forced interest rate increase, would likely result in runaway inflation almost overnight. The result would be a huge blow to a still deteriorating economy.
3) Engineer a stock market collapse. Recently investors have, rightfully, realized there is no more risk in equities, not because the assets backing the stockholder equity are actually creating greater cash flow (as we demonstrated recently, that is not the case), but simply because taxpayers have involuntarily become safekeepers for the entire stock market, due to Bernanke's forced intervention in bond and equity markets. Yet the President's Working Group is fully aware that when the time comes to hitting the "reverse" button, it will do so. Will the resultant rush into safe assets be sufficient to generate the needed endogenous demand for Treasuries is unknown. It will likely be correlated to the size of the equity market drop.
If the Fed decides on option three, we fully believe a 30% drop (or greater) in equities is very probable as the new supply/demand regime in fixed income becomes apparent. We hope mainstream media takes the ideas presented here and processes them for broader consumption as indeed the Fed is caught in a very fragile dilemma, and the sooner its hand is pushed, the less disastrous the final outcome for investors. Then again, as Eric Sprott has been pointing out for quite some time, it could very well be that the US economy has become merely one huge Ponzi, and as such, its expansion or reduction on the margin is uncontrollable. We very well may have passed into the stage where blind growth is the only alternative to a complete collapse. We hope that is not the case.

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays to all readers."

I'll leave you tonight to draw your own conclusions. However, it does seem a bit coincidental that, just when treasury issuance begins anew at record levels, the world is suddenly, once again rushing toward the "safety" of U.S. government bonds. Oh, and remember, in the markets, there are no coincidences.

Rest well. Not only will tomorrow be crazy, next week will undoubtedly be memorable, too. TF

About the Author

turd [at] tfmetalsreport [dot] com ()


treefrog · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:08pm

gold trying to get through

gold trying to get through sixteen fifty ...again silver getting a little traction. maybe.... just maybe.


edit: there's 16,50!

flaunt · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:09pm



Shill · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:13pm

Waiting a little longer TURD

Patiently waiting to pull the trigger on TBT Turd.

ginger · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:17pm

Dennis Kneale on Fox News

Dennis Kneale on Fox News just now told Gretta re: the stock market, 'if you don't sell, you haven't lost' .....He went on to say that he didn't sell any part of his portfolio in any of the crashes and he was 'made whole' again. ......THAT is the kind of thinking that is pervasive out there. They just don't realize how different it is going to be once all of the ponzi comes crashing down. Really makes me fearful for people everywhere.

Repost from last thread:

kliguy, I always find myself wishing you'd elaborate juuuust a little bit more. indecision ..I understand WHAT you are saying.. just want to hear more. You caution to 'remain disciplined and in this environment dry powder can become a premium as liquidity dries up'. I have been waiting on my 'dry powder' for a month and should have it within the next 2 weeks. ...Do you believe I will have missed the boat by then? ...As you know, I am not a trader but I had planned to divide my 'dry powder' between allocations of 1) physical, 2) miner shares, 3) options call/puts. ...Worried now that I may miss a rocket launch but it is what it is. I know there is always another trade ..but one has to wonder if that window is closing. Anyway... I read you religously and thank you for popping in here and posting with your insights.

Kumanari, you said: "Not all rich people are thieves....., some are grandchildren of thieves." ..... ..Are you speaking from personal experience in the lineage? :D .......there was more than one benefit to those knee high fences in Macon, eh? :)

Just kidding. .....Gorgeous waterfall video. ....DO NOT tell me that is your back yard. .....sigh..... surprise

Shill · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:22pm
Dr Durden · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:25pm

Wise words and keen analysis,

Wise words and keen analysis, Turdy.

Engineered? You bet your sweet ass. No way I can come close to any MSM website or "news'paper" anymore without barfing all over it. It seriously makes me ill.

left right wrong · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:31pm
Paladex · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:37pm

Armstrong on Bonds

In case you missed Martin Armstrong's answer to the question "Why are bonds rallying?" 

Armstrong Economics: Why Bonds Always Rally?

As for engineering a stock market collapse ... It hardly needs to be "engineered," IMHO ... All they have to do is step back for a moment, and it collapses by itself.

So It Goes · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:40pm

Thanks Turd

December 23, 1776

THESE are the times that try men's souls. The summer soldier and the sunshine patriot will, in this crisis, shrink from the service of their country; but he that stands by it now, deserves the love and thanks of man and woman.

Thomas Paine

History is repeating - turbulent times are coming.

Thanks Turd. Your voice "deserves the love and thanks of man and woman." This website is patriotic - please keep up the good work.

Maryann · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:41pm

Thank you

Turd, I just had to add my voice to to the many who have already expressed so much gratitude to you. You are able to put together the big pieces of all this craziness going on in a way that I can understand. You are able to take complex topics and explain them so that I can make the best decisions I can to help my family.

I will be eternally grateful, and I know you will be eternally blessed for the work you are doing. Thank you again.

bbdgoco · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:45pm

ginger and maryann on the same thread?


The weather started getting rough, the tiny ship was tossed.

Think I'll quit while I'm behind.

TitanAe · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:49pm

Not too long ago !!!

Everyone was asking who would buy U.S treasuries !?!?! Now we know who, Create panic in the stock market and the scared little investor will !!! GOOD JOB !!! Mr GOVERMENT !!!!

GoldistheFuture · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:49pm

Option 3?

If option 3 is what they are doing that means we still have about a 20% drop. Ouch!! I better go out and buy a couple Liter bottles of Vodka to weather the storm. lol

grinners · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:52pm


I've got some of my money (15%) in a nice little bio-plastics company in aus with a ton of potential but the state of the economy is just killing it at the moment...

Having bio-degradeable wrapping is the last thing on the conglomerates minds at the moment I think. 20% drop today :( I don't mind sitting it out, I just hope the company can survive it though!

(For those interested, 65% in PM's, 20% in cash)

Eric Original · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:57pm

@ Bull re: FSG

FSG is a good vehicle to ride a declining Dow-Gold Ratio trade (though technically it is short the S & P 500 instead of the Dow).

Highly leveraged, very low volume, of course it's been on a screaming tear lately. Be Careful.

TheGoodDoctor · Aug 4, 2011 - 10:58pm

@Turd So collapse and then

@Turd So collapse and then QEIII? This has been my expectation to get to QEIII they need a collapse and fear.

Prize Fighter · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:00pm

Great post Turd and a good

Great post Turd and a good memory to boot.

I don't believe in coincidences either but I do believe in serendipity. Whatever will be will be. You can either pay attention to the signs nature gives us or you can be naturally selected.

side note: Serendipity was derived from the word Serendib which is what Arab traders used to call Ceylon, now known as Sri Lanka. 

It was series of serendipitous events which led me to that island nation once upon a time. And believe it or not, it was that journey which allowed me to take the red pill upon my return home in '06. These details are unimportant to all but they are everything to me. You wouldn't believe me if I told you anyway. You don't have to, just believe in YOUR signs. 

I kinda think if you're reading this though, you already have. Welcome travelers, you're among friends.

Shill · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:01pm
ScottJ · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:04pm

The Coming Days

Excellent Post Turd, I like how you lead the reader the best you can. Very nice style indeed.

A few points I would like to mention.

  • We often are very tunnel-visioned in US Centric mindset. Admittedly we are not focusing as much as how this affects all of Europe (a much larger population to riot, especially one who is discontent in the Euro in the first place). It is very well that even if the US stays asleep through financial collapse, the Europeans will know the scoop with their own ponzi scheme they have going on (The Euro). They have been through rises and falls of financial systems in their history, they are no rookies in financial collapse over there compared to the American Dream we have.... I hope there is a revolution of mindset occurring there!
  • Inflationary conditions often lead to wartime situations. With the middle east up in flames with political coups happening in the name of freedom, the western world foreign policy may pre-emptively start world war III by dragging in the Eastern World countries. This violence is unnecessary and provoked, as we should not be in any military situations over there. If there is a world war occurring, and we have a financial collapse of the economic system, it would be the perfect time for the western banking cartel to implement a new currency. Personal thoughts are it may be highly digital and will be some sort of pegging system. Eitherway, this would be terrible news, so we must resist this route. 
  • When Gold and Silver start doing well, it will not be easy to call for the changes needed which will directly benefit metal owners financial situation when it will be bankrupting so many. 
  • There are more people than not who do not know what these next several weeks are going to mean to them. It may not even affect them as they do not have any money in the equity markets (most people are in debt, not in stocks). When you sit with your losses, know that there are billions of people around the world that are going to be affected by the implications of what the next few weeks of fiscal policy, and they are helpless. If you are aware, you are winning. Your biggest asset in the coming days is your mind.
  • Many who want to look at what is going on are too busy and too inundated with the stresses of "life" that society has placed upon them. Give people a break, we are coming to a crossroads... we need as many open minded people in the coming days. You can't hide with physical, food/water, and guns in the west if tyranny is afoot. If freedom is lost in the coming days, then it is over for all of us, me included. Don't be fooled by the comforts of what we know as normal, as much of what we are living on is on the back of others. The slavery system still exists alive and well, but the coming days are all about what happens when the slave sees who the master is....

QE-III next week hinted at, formal implementation late august is my guess.

Be careful out there, but don't shut out those around you that are willing to talk. There will be many new open eyes and ears in short amount of time...

Ron Paul is a good vehicle for political enlightenment.

Scott J

S Roche · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:04pm

Key Reversal / Outside Reversal Day Silver

Thanks Turd, makes sense.

I would also point out that they painted a big fat Outside Reversal Day on the daily silver chart...textbook version.

So, for the nimble!

Dr Durden · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:15pm

We're just back to were we

We're just back to were we should be. The "engineering" is the big ass hump you see in the middle. How much can the WS $$ whore vacuum suck out of it before it's got nothing left. I guess today they lost suction. *insert Spaceballs line: "It's the maid, she's gone from suck to blow!" *

TheGoodDoctor · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:21pm

@ScottJ That web site doesn't

@ScottJ That web site doesn't work for that chart.

What is that queasy feeling you have left me with ScottJ?

Maryann bbdgoco · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:25pm


Ginger certainly had the thought first, I just jumped onboard... :D

Shill · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:35pm
TheGoodDoctor · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:38pm

Asia down big.

Asia down big.

ScottJ TheGoodDoctor · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:39pm


To be honest, I found that chart on a random blog post, and I have been linking it myself. I never checked the website presented on it (go figure), but I think its content speaks for itself. A very very good perspective of how far we have come as human beings in the consciousness.

And as for those queasy feelings, those are yours not mine surprise, as we all control our own feelings! However, I would venture to guess emotional response to realities that may be parts of the truth regarding how some would like to see this macro-scene play out. I for one, do not wish to venture down this road. You are aware, that is what is most important. 

Think about the statistical probability of being aware and alive at this exact moment of time. Never before have we as human beings, no less the serfs, been so aware to who we are, what is going on around us, and what is coming our way.

There are countless people who have roamed this planet who could only dream of the situation that we are in. Let's try to make something of it.~

· Aug 4, 2011 - 11:45pm

Best Post Ever, Turd

Brilliant analysis. Three choices, Fed has tried QE: fail. Fed cannot try higher interest rates, for political reasons. Hence, the Fed's third choice. Simple, elegant, correct = brilliant.

No wonder I read this site all day long . . .

SilverTree · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:46pm

I love you guys! I wish you

I love you guys! I wish you all the best in these wild times. -ST

Sitting Bull · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:52pm

TF & ZH Nail It!

Excellent post Mr. Ferguson. Behind Door #3 lies the prize that worked so well for the EE 80 years ago. See Mile High by Condon.

The ironies abound.

The EE's own Soros signals the collapse of the market.

Investors flee to cash, just before a new round of money printing is announced and the dollar sinks.

Investment advice: After you've stocked enough gold/silver and bullets, buy wheelbarrows -- everyone will need one to haul cash to the grocery store.

agNau · Aug 4, 2011 - 11:54pm
Become a gold member and subscribe to Turd's Vault


Donate  Shop

Get Your Subscriber Benefits

Exclusive discount for silver purchases, and a private iTunes feed for TF Metals Report podcasts!

Key Economic Events week of 12/10

12/11 8:30 ET Producer Price Index
12/12 8:30 ET Consumer Price Index
12/13 8:30 ET Import Price Index
12/14 8:30 ET Retail Sales
12/14 9:15 ET Industrial Prod. and Cap. Utilization
12/14 10:00 ET Business Inventories

Key Economic Events week of 11/26

11/27 9:00 ET Case-Schiller home prices
11/27 10:00 ET Consumer Confidence
11/28 8:30 ET Q3 GDP 2nd guess
11/28 10:00 ET New home sales
11/29 8:30 ET Personal Income and Spending
11/29 10:00 ET Pending home sales
11/29 2:00 ET November FOMC minutes

Key Economic Events week of 11/19

11/20 8:30 ET Housing Starts
11/21 8:30 ET Durable Goods
11/21 10:00 ET UMich Sentiment
11/21 10:00 ET LEIII
11/21 10:00 ET Existing Home Sales