Trend Following Discussion

125 posts / 0 new
Last post
atlee
atlee's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 12262
Posts: 1431
Rico wrote: The alternative

Rico wrote:

The alternative is short-term trading, but then you are constantly having to make entry/exit decisions, which I have found burns most traders out, sooner or later.  The winning percentage may be quite high, but the big wins never materialize, and modest results are often the best that can be achieved--and after all that work!

Ah yes but nothing feels better than opening a position and having it move immediately in your direction without ever looking back! Very hard to do and never expected but when it does, ...that is perfection. Then you wish you had opened with a larger position!!!

You are doing a fantastic job here Rico! Keep up the great work. I think this is a valuable and much needed forum. This is where anyone who buys or sells paper assets should start.

Congrats man!yesyesyes

__________________

So when your down on your luck and you can't harmonize, find a girl with far away eyes.

Rico
Rico's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 5557
Posts: 1626
atlee wrote: Ah yes but

atlee wrote:

Ah yes but nothing feels better than opening a position and having it move immediately in your direction without ever looking back! Very hard to do and never expected but when it does, ...that is perfection. 

Absolutely, bro--those quick hits never get old!yes

sixdollarsilver
sixdollarsilver's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/26/2011
Hat Tips: 1547
Posts: 875
The rush

atlee wrote:

Ah yes but nothing feels better than opening a position and having it move immediately in your direction without ever looking back! Very hard to do and never expected but when it does, ...that is perfection. Then you wish you had opened with a larger position!!!

You are doing a fantastic job here Rico! Keep up the great work. I think this is a valuable and much needed forum. This is where anyone who buys or sells paper assets should start.

Congrats man!yesyesyes

Couldn't agree more.

Vypuero
Vypuero's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 3995
Posts: 1110
Hate when this happens

I was stopped out at the spike bottoms and we recovered.  Happens a lot the damn market makers do it to screw you.  Nevertheless don't really like the short term action here so I am waiting until a better set up or a stronger dip.  I still have my options positions so that is not so bad.

P.S. I signed up for Chris Vermeulen "Gold and Oil Guy" reports.  I will try it to see if he pays off for a few months.  I have been following his free videos and I like the technical analysis he does.

My stock picks are all doing nicely - I bought MA and ATRO when the MACD crossed and both came out with great earnings and are up significantly.  I plan to take profits when the trend starts to falter (usually you will see either the crossover or the MA 9 start moving outside the bars).  Another good one is MDCO.  I bought that awhile back I think because I saw a trend reversal set up (RSI or SSTO divergence).  I can't remember any more, but I will ride it until it loses momentum too.

crinerc
crinerc's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/24/2011
Hat Tips: 37
Posts: 51
Ok so a little more on the triple screen trading system

Alexander Elder describes the longer term chart(weekly) as being like the tide in the ocean.  So you always want to trade with the tide, and never against it.  Then the intermediate term chart(daily) is like the waves within the the tide.  Obviously the waves ebb and flow within the tide, but the tide always sets the direction.  I think this is a pretty cool analogy being that I like to surf.

"Therefore daily rallies provide great shorting opportunities while the trend is down".   Obviously the opposite is true, and applies here as well.  

"Triple screen trading begins with the long term chart, one time-frame longer than the one you plan to trade.  Most traders pay attention only to the daily charts,  with everybody watching the same few months of data.  If you begin by analyzing the weekly charts, your perspective will be five times greater than that of your competitors."  

"The original system uses the slope of the MACD Histogram on the weekly chart to identify the market trend(or tide).   The slope is defined as the relationship between the two latest bars.  If the slope is up the bulls are in control, and it is time to trade from the long side.  If the slope is down, the opposite is true."  

A single uptick or downtick on the MACD histogram indicates a change of trend.  Up-ticks below the center-line, and down-ticks above the center-line give better buy and sell signals, than buying above and selling below.   The absolute best signal is when the trend changes from buy to sell at extremes above the centerline, and from sell to buy at extremes below the centerline.

So the idea of the first screen is to decide whether to go long, short, or stand aside.  The direction of the histogram eliminates either the long or short part of the equation.  "You have to swim with the tide or stay out of the water".  

The second screen is the "wave" direction within the tide.  The waves that go against the tide/trend represent your long/short opportunities.   These are found on your daily chart, and use an oscillator as the trigger for the trade.  Any oscillator should do, but I will use stochastics as an example.  When the trend is down, a stoch. reading of 70 or above indicates an overbought condition, and indicates a shorting opportunity, and vice versa.  

"The third screen identifies the ripples in the direction of the tide.  It uses intraday price action to pinpoint entry points.  The third screen does not require a chart or an indicator.  It is a technique for entering the market after the first, and second screen have given the signal to go long or short.  It is a trailing buy-stop in an up-trending market, or a trailing sell-stop in a down-trending market.  They catch the upside and downside breakouts."

I will use the trailing buy-stop as an example.  When your daily oscillator rises from its over-sold condition, you place a buy-stop one tick above the previous day's high.  If the prices rally, you will automatically be stopped in once the price rallies through the previous day's high.  If prices continue to decline, your buy-stop will not be touched.  Continue to lower your buy-stop entry each day until you are stopped in, or the weekly chart changes direction and your order is canceled.   

Active traders can use the daily oscillators as new entry points for pyramiding, or increasing original position size.  Stops should be fairly tight in case the trade doesn't work out, but according to each individual's risk/reward.  To exit, the trend may be followed until the weekly histogram changes direction to capture the whole trend, or you can use the daily oscillator to capture the large moves within the trend.

Hope you guys find this useful.  A video I watched recently from Alessio Rastani advises switching the MACD from a 12/26, to a 20/43.  Which uses the centerline more effectively, and captures more of the whole trend.  It smoothes out the histogram as well which would be good for this system.

Quotations above were direct quotes from Alex Elder, that I took directly out of the book "Trading for a living".  UNG looks like it has turned up on the weekly histogram, so I am waiting for a buy signal.  I will let you know how it plays out along with the details!

__________________

Ben Bernanke never held a job in his entire life outside of academia and the Fed. His knowledge of reality stops at the back cover of the textbooks he studies and the ridiculous theory-based papers he has written.

Vypuero
Vypuero's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 3995
Posts: 1110
crinerc pretty good stuff

Overall I have to say I agree with a system like that.  I was unhappy being stopped out today but looking at the charts they did what they were supposed to!  The trend is no longer up on the daily, and while it is on the weekly I need to re-enter after I get a better signal.  It was just a bad move on my part where I bought gold, totally botched it.  So I am re-assessing my re-entry point which was always a bit too vague.

I also plan to use the weekly MACD crossovers as positions to buy into longer term spreads, which I did well in silver and I jumped the gun on gold - broke rule and didn't wait for the signal to confirm, it was just "almost" there.  Still think I am ok on it though but I at the very least lost profit by jumping too soon.

Rico
Rico's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 5557
Posts: 1626
@crinerc, Outstanding post!

@crinerc,

Outstanding post!  I'll be spending some time with that stuff tonight.  Excellent!yes

crinerc
crinerc's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/24/2011
Hat Tips: 37
Posts: 51
Thanks Rico!  I think instead

Thanks Rico!  I think instead of using an oscillator, I will be using the trailing buy-stop on any down days.  Did quite a bit of back-testing with the oscillators, and there just aren't enough entry points.  Like gold for instance, there would have been no place for entry this whole run up.  But if you would have trailed any down days, it would have been a great entry.  Or even a pull-back on the daily histogram has netted good results.   Time to test her out!

Vypuero - I think you will get that MACD cross shortly after this correction in gold.  Really hoping for a good sized dip tomorrow or Wednesday.  If this was it I will be very disappointed .  

__________________

Ben Bernanke never held a job in his entire life outside of academia and the Fed. His knowledge of reality stops at the back cover of the textbooks he studies and the ridiculous theory-based papers he has written.

Vypuero
Vypuero's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 3995
Posts: 1110
oscillators

I still like my MA5/13 cross as an entry.  The MACD cross is also a good entry.

Rico
Rico's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 5557
Posts: 1626
The new short CL trade is

The new short CL trade is moving in the right direction, so far.  A move down through 95.5-95.4, especially if it came today/tomorrow would be very positive, as it would establish a new low.

That three-stage Elder framework that Crinerc explained looks very solid, particularly for what I call "prospecting"--looking for markets to trade.  You can just flip through weeklies of various futures, then narrow down the promising ones to dailies, etc.  I usually do that kind of thing on the weekends, when the markets are closed.  Everything's quiet, and I can think.

Using Stage 3 for trading long or short within the trend is a potentially additive profit parameter, a way of integrating the shorter trading timeframes.

Vypuero
Vypuero's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 3995
Posts: 1110
@Rico - Oil

$95 is resistance - depending on what you have it would seem a good trade to take 1/2 profit there and the rest on a break down through to maybe $92-$93.  That is from what I saw of the latest Technical Traders video.

Markets are in transition now waiting for a break one way or another.  I am holding off new positions until some direction becomes clear.  Thoughts are we are close to a break down in the market, with the dollar up and PMs down some more.  When is the question.  Then likely a small bounce and a heavier drop after that.  Could get interesting soon.

crinerc
crinerc's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/24/2011
Hat Tips: 37
Posts: 51
UNG has given a buy signal, I

UNG has given a buy signal, I will be placing a trailing buy-stop at today's high of $5.52.  If tomorrow moves lower, I will set the buy-stop at tomorrow's high.

SOHU has also just changed direction on the weekly.  Looking for some up-days for an entry.  Rico, if you see any equities you like as you are scanning  please share them with us.  I will do the same, currently looking for some stock lists to go over in the evenings.

__________________

Ben Bernanke never held a job in his entire life outside of academia and the Fed. His knowledge of reality stops at the back cover of the textbooks he studies and the ridiculous theory-based papers he has written.

Vypuero
Vypuero's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 3995
Posts: 1110
looks like it didn't happen

Instead we got a reversal, so we have more upside before we get a correction.  The Euro broke out of its box, and I went long the Euro at $1.324 - I will look to ride it up maybe 100 points or so.  While I missed a lot of upside in Silver and Gold, I don't feel bad as it was not predictable.  I also still have profit because my option values have gone back up.

bigmark99
bigmark99's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 548
Posts: 70
Just a thought, If your going

Just a thought, If your going to use Moving averages. Use the Exponential Moving Averages. They are a better moving average because the last 3 days are weighted, more accurate and since they are a 20 day avg, quicker response to the market.

I use the ema and the ma when I'm looking for tops or bottoms in the stock market, so far so good.

Sorry for any spelling errors

                                           Me

Vypuero
Vypuero's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 3995
Posts: 1110
I prefer the normal MA

Not sure why but the EMA seems too jagged and for the way I am using them the normal works better.

Rico
Rico's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 5557
Posts: 1626
Did I mention my CL short

Did I mention my CL short didn't work out? LOL ;-)

CK
CK's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/15/2011
Hat Tips: 3714
Posts: 607
I know this isn't a day

I know this isn't a day trading thread, but I do think that this system works pretty well for that too.. on the shorter time frames of course.  Such as the 5 min, 15 min etc.

It's a lot more work and not really needed.  Best is to stick with the dailys. Get some really nice big moves.  

Interesting day for crude oil coming up tomorrow. Inventories usually have some nice moves. Big inside range 99.13 - 95.84.  Do we break out above 99.13 and have an outside range for the day?  We shall see.

Bonds and the dollar are on sell signals but that can all change really fast.  Super interesting market right now.  S & P near the highs of 2011.. Something tells me we might see a flash crash later this year :) 

Will the s & p make new highs? (above 1370) If not look out!!

__________________

We're not trading against the market, we're trading against ourselves.

crinerc
crinerc's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/24/2011
Hat Tips: 37
Posts: 51
Alex Elder did mentioned that

Alex Elder did mentioned that the system can be used for shorter time frames, and the the long term chart must be about 5 times longer than your intermediate chart.  So if you like to trade the 10 minute chart, then you would use the one hour chart to identify the trend.  I already do something similar to this in my regular trading.  If the two hour MACD hasn't turned up yet after a market correction, I use the 30 minute to identify the immediate trend, then I use the 5 minute MACD cross under the centerline to execute my trade.  I like to use the 2 hour as my general market direction indicator.   So far hasn't steered me wrong.

I'm kind of in the same boat with Silver Wealth on crude.  There is a lot of strong support near the mid 90's, and with the political issues going on in the middle-east, for me it's just to risky.  If that sharp rally today had happened overnight last night, I would have been extremely underwater when I woke up this morning.  That is the last place I want to be.  Sometimes the fundamentals overtake the chart patterns.  I would say it's rare, but it happens.

__________________

Ben Bernanke never held a job in his entire life outside of academia and the Fed. His knowledge of reality stops at the back cover of the textbooks he studies and the ridiculous theory-based papers he has written.

crinerc
crinerc's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/24/2011
Hat Tips: 37
Posts: 51
UNG- New entry is a break

UNG- New entry is a break above today's high of $5.33.

SOHU- Entry is a break below today's low of 51.70.  (unless it goes lower before EOD)

__________________

Ben Bernanke never held a job in his entire life outside of academia and the Fed. His knowledge of reality stops at the back cover of the textbooks he studies and the ridiculous theory-based papers he has written.

Vypuero
Vypuero's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/14/2011
Hat Tips: 3995
Posts: 1110
Euro update

took profit at 1.3310 as I am too nervous about how volatile the trade is and subject to every rumor about Greece.  

Might cash out of my MA call soon as I think the $400 price range will offer some psychological resistance.  If my price hits I will be out.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Syndicate content Comments for "Trend Following Discussion"