TFMR Podcast #18 - The Return of Ranting Andy
Download Podcast (Right Click + 'Save As')
Late on Thursday, I had an opportunity to visit again with "Ranting" Andy Hoffman of Miles Franklin.
When we last spoke back in December, the metals were making lows and were soon to recover. As fate would have it, in the time since, we've seen a tremendous rally that led to the "Leap Day Violation" and subsequent pressuring of the metals all the way to the lows of this past Wednesday. So, under similar circumstances to last December, Andy and I discuss market manipulation, the godforsaken miners and the question of whether silver is money.
I'm quite certain that you'll enjoy this podcast.
TF
Andy Hoffman

Andrew ("Andy") Hoffman joined Miles Franklin as Marketing Director in October 2011. For a decade, he was a U.S.-based buy-side and sell-side analyst, most notably as a II-ranked oil service analyst at Salomon Smith Barney. Since 2002, his focus has been entirely on Precious Metals, and since 2006 has written under the moniker "Ranting Andy." Prior to joining the Miles Franklin, he spent five years working as an Investor Relations officer or consultant to numerous junior mining companies. An archive of Andy's "rants" can be found on the Miles Franklin Blog here:
http://blog.milesfranklin.com/category/authors/andrew-hoffman
-
Friday, April 27, 2012
-
Friday, December 23, 2011
Support TF Metals Report with a donation or by purchasing something from the TurdMart Store.




Comments
As to the speculation of the
As to the speculation of the total failure of paper markets, well if that happens, we are all screwed no matter how much you have in your stack. 401k's, saving's accounts, and everything else will be lost and no matter of FDIC insurance is gonna bail you out. Not only will financial markets close, we would see a total close of the flow of commerce. Could this happen? I guess it could. Your stack will be rendered fairly useless when there is no commerce. But unless it's an act of God or a nuclear blow out, I don't see this happening tomorrow. If it does, you better be well prepared in your underground shelter. One of the problems I have noticed is that there is a mismatch between possible future events, and the reality which we are living now. And being too early to the party can be equally detrimental as not showing up for the party. I am going to live in the moment and act based upon the current water conditions. It doesn't mean I am unaware of future conditions. But if you drive looking too far down the road, you're gonna hit a camel in the middle of the road. Being far sighted is no better than being near sighted.
GL - well said as always
I totally agree - and it would be true of someone who invested in tech stocks and got out at the right moment, and someone who rode Nortel to the ground - they would have completely different outlooks.
And to follow up on a point you made - inflation is a monetary event - all prices rise as the currency gets debased - gas prices going up, per se, is not inflation. Just a pedantic, Milton Friedman point - which I wanted to bring to the fore. People mistake rising prices in a sector for inflation, and this is relevant to the gold bubble nonsense being put out there. The price of gold is not rising, the currencies are failing.
XTY, You are absolutely
XTY,
You are absolutely correct about inflation being a monetary event. Rising prices are not inflation. They are a result of the devaluing of the currency and thus it requires more of it to buy the same thing. Prices will rise not because they are worth more, just that it will take more fiat to buy the same thing. That's also why gold is a great insurance but a poor investment. When that gold coin is worth $5000.00, you will only be able to purchase things that used to be only worth $1000.00. That's not a great investment but a wonderful way to preserve what you have. To grow your money, you'll either need to find the trend in speculative investments, there is always something that performs well, or have another source of fiat which hopefully you'll put into something that will preserve that wealth as currency continues to be devalued.
The decision people are making to invest in paper is a conscious one that says, I am gonna need a heck alot more physical to survive this thing. If your wealth is such that you don't need to grow it and only need preservation, then you are in good shape. Glad so many are in that position. Because those who do believe that their will be calamity and markets of all kinds will close, will need alot of nuggets to get by until things return to normal. Of course, I hope it doesn't come to that.
Rage against the system
Good thoughts GL.
Rants and raves against the system and the grave injustices are all well and good for blowing off some steam, but if that steam turns into a cloud that blinds our judgment, we are led into poor decision making. When we think something is unfair, we already have a bias for the fair outcome. Nothing wrong with that, that is our moral compass. But if we make investment decisions based on our ideas of fair and unfair, we can be deaf to what the market is telling us. I have been guilty of that several times and paid the price. Hopefully the lessons learned and wiser heads here will help me make better decisions as we move forward.
The unfolding of the action in the miners is going to very interesting, for those (like me) who have skin in the game and for those that don't. But, as you say, that's the risk/reward that we choose. I have chosen the rollercoaster. Wheeeee, been up and whooosh been down. Will it go up again or is this the end of the ride? Will I choose when to get off, or will I be thrown off?
@Green Lantern
There will be irrational over pricing in the metals in the mania phase, so it's also a good investment if you step out at the right moment.
Investing:
Only the dogs know where his gold stash is hidden
http://news.petpardons.com/starving-dogs-survive-on-corpse-of-owner/
Reuters changes the MOPE on Friday
8:15 a.m.:
Fri Apr 27, 2012 8:15am EDT
* Euro recovers losses but confidence in gold still weak
* S&P downgrades Spain rating by two notches
* Silver off three-month low but heads for weekly loss (Updates prices)
And 3:45 p.m.:
Gold posts biggest weekly rise since late February
Fri Apr 27, 2012 3:45pm EDT
(Reuters) - Gold rose for a fourth consecutive session on Friday and posted its biggest weekly gain since late February, as disappointing U.S. growth and European debt jitters boosted investment demand for the precious metal.
Bullion buying accelerated after a report showed U.S. economic growth cooled in the first quarter as businesses cut back on investment.
Some safe-haven demand also supported prices after a credit downgrade of Spain's sovereign debt by Standard & Poor's.
Gold's four-day rise was underpinned by option-related buying and after Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke said on Wednesday the U.S. central bank would not hesitate to launch another round of bond purchases to boost growth if necessary....
http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/04/27/us-markets-precious-idUSBRE839...
@Zilverreiger
If we acknowledge there will be a mania phase, Gosh I hope, then it seems like the time to buy is NOW! Unless you think things are going lower. These are 2008 prices all over again. Sometimes, the price is low enough. If you are already in at higher prices, just chill.
I dunno 'bout you...
but in my VERY humble opinion, the POSX is headed lower and quickly.
Been looking at the following all morning: Weekly, Daily, 4hr (key chart), 1hr, 10min.
USD/JPY... broke support Friday in a BIG way
AUD/USD... big pop off of support on Friday
WTI... nice break through resistance on Friday and support looks good.
Silver... nice break through resistance with a pullback to support still happening. Expect a bounce and rally this week.
If you're a stacker, may be the cheapest chance to buy right now. I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say that $30 was the bottom. You may get a pullback after the upcoming rally, when the POSX bounces off the 200ma, but it'll be back to the $32 range after we smack $33.50 or maybe $34... and after that, I'd bet we see the Silver climb begin. It'll be a slow climb until we break the $37.50 area again, with a pullback here and there... but a climb none the less. I guess if you stack a few oz's at a time, a dollar or two doesn't mean anything. And it shouldn't. Just get it. Period. Your family will be glad you did. If you still swap paper...well, best of luck to you. I hope you're doing good with your profits. There are lots of folks who would love to be in your shoes. Consider yourself blessed to be able to do so.
Big prediction: 2nd week of June... SPY will take off...as the POSX tanks below the 200ma. Spain will be a non-stop headline maker, with Italy waiting in the wings.
Really sucks... nice to see Silver showing signs of life, but all of us who live in the US and have to budget are going to get smacked with a new round of higher prices for essentials, while our non-essentials (and real estate) lose value. Don't get me wrong, we've had it too good for too long...we've become complacent. But other people all over the world have it much, much worse. It's time we took our medicine. Sucks...but it's unavoidable.
Oh, and yes, I realize it's all "manipulated"... but c'mon, you cannot deny the trends. You just can't. They tell you everything. We're living the collapse... one day at a time.
Just some random thoughts. Check the charts...what do you see??
Oh...btw... THANKS TF! Great interview with Andy!
Be well, y'all!
C1
Gold chart spied on Jesse
- from Sharelynx originally.
Had lunch on Friday with a guy I know who runs a $2bn commodities trading fund. He told me Gold had broken down on the long-term chart. Not sure what we had been drinking the night before but I know he'd been to an expensive nightclub...! I of course informed him to the contrary, but he seemed convinced in his view. He was VERY long Silver when it broke out a month or so (and then got smashed back below the breakout trend) and now says Silver is also D.O.A. To me this is all very bullish; a serious market professional who wants to own both metals, has been shaken out of both by the cartel machinations. I reminded him he was taking the contrary view to the commercials by being out now and that did at least elicit a smile. He knows what to expect from Permabull Tabberto so didn't seem keen to listen to the fundamental case. These guys still have FULL FAITH in the credit notes of Uncle Sam as the only place to take refuge. Amazing really but supports the case that we are only transitioning to phase 2 of the secular Bull right now....
21 Sad Facts About The Deindustrialization Of (the West)
Europe is a high technology zone and this gives me hope. Check out some quality stuff that you may see wizzin' past your window.
I loudly support my fellow worker.
21 Sad Facts About The Deindustrialization Of Britain (& applicable to most western nations) :-
Now, those factories and mines are closing, and those workers aren't working. In the past 30 years the deindustralization of the country has accelerated rapidly, leaving many people behind.
We've assembled some important facts that will show you exactly how the World's first industrial nation has become the world's first post-industrial nation — and what this means for the average Brit.
http://www.businessinsider.com/uk-factory-job-loss-oil-2011-11?op=1
@ Tabberto - Sunday Morning ruminations
Thanks for all your great contributions.
Without referencing the charts, here's a totally gut interpretation of current status.
EE has been accumulating shorts here for months to keep price down on PMs.
They have also been sucking-in longs here. In order to suck in the last of the 'fence-sitting longs' they
serve us a 'head-fake' little up-spurt, [which we just saw], then they pull one of their infamous 'flash-crash' events
so they can clear their shorts and buy long at the instantaneous bottom.
Which also serves to blow-out the stops on all the longs held by the traders, {all ten of those jokers who are still in the game,
you know who you are~(!)}, and then further serves to flog the stackers, who
at this point are so fatigued they can't hardly muster the strength to scream or moan.
OK> that's my Sunday morning ruminations,
What a confession.
Feel like I've been to church.
Church of the Reformed PM Trader ~!
I think this is going to be important
Said it before, but 15 trillion to 16 trillion happened really quickly - this could happen faster than they think. Then the headlines will turn towards the States, and away from Europe, and the slow, managed, descent of both currencies can continue. But I think gold will have to nudge up.
"Debt ceiling looms again – Congress has a full plate
12 April 2012
The US government might be bumping up against the debt ceiling
already by October, at the height of the presidential election
campaign and significantly earlier than many analysts seem to
expect.
• According to the White House’s 2013 budget proposal (hidden
in Table 6-2), US federal debt subject to the statutory
borrowing limit will be USD 16,333.9bn on 30 September
2012. The debt ceiling is USD 16,394bn.
• The possibility of reaching a deal to raise the debt ceiling is
pretty slim before the election.
• Therefore, the Treasury will likely use the same accounting
moves as last year to push the drop-dead date until after the
election. So by January 2013 at the latest, the debt ceiling will
have to be raised again at the same time as significant tax-cut
expirations and spending reductions are set to take effect. ...
...
Risk of a major political accident is very real,
and it might come sooner rather than later."
http://newsroom.nordeamarkets.com/en/files/2012/04/Debt-ceiling-April-20...
You may be right abguy4
indeed, you may well be right....I bloody hope not though, that much I can tell you!
The USD/Gold battle for trendlines is fascinating at the moment. Absent a market event (Spain/France somesuch or geopolitical) imo both secular trendlines will hold - IE Gold will bounce and $ will fail and fall lower...usually it serves to watch the primary trend and forgo all others in my limited experience. I would also add that should the bearish market event happen, then I believe there will be REAL fear, meaning Gold will revert to risk-off rather than risk-on status, something which seems to only happen when markets get properly skittish. Eurozone buying of Gold would surely skyrocket as and when their problems reemerge with a vengeance.
My bigdog friend, interestingly, was also whingeing about copper being routinely manipulated by GS, i could sense the discomfort of the other 4 (this is a periodic friends in the sector lunch/piss-up) as a grin appeared on my face. For YEARS the boys at the lunch have hooted whenever I bring up the JPM/Silver situation but they looked rather sheepish despite all agreeing with bigdog that I was mad to still be in Gold and Silver. They also struggled to disagree that it was highly bullish that Blythe had publicly denied manipulating Silver - seemed amazed as I recounted that particular gem of a CNBC special.....
The debt level is going up like a....
...screaming jet.
That's the fastest trillion I've seen accumulated yet and it's quickening.
Bad outcome likely on the red ink horizon....
"Maple Tree Eats Chain Link Fence" by Driven81 !
Borrowing from Oil Field Recovery Technology....Quebecers are connecting Maple trees with galvanized pipe to automate the tedious recovery of Maple sap ! Oui Oui Oui ! Monedas 1929 Comedy Jihad Jack My Flap !
PS: Thanks again to Rantin' Andy and Turd "The Turd" Ferguson for great interview....I actually listened to the whole thing ! PSS: Flap Jacks, Hot Cakes, Pan Cakes....shouldn't Flap Jacks be called "Flip Jacks" or "Flip Flaps" ? Hot Cakes should be "Flip Cakes"....we know they're hot ? Pan Cakes should be "Pan Crepes" ? Flipped Pan Crepes ? Anyway, they're always better with Maple syrup, real butter and CANNED BACON ! The World according to Monedas 1929 ! 
$1300 to $2000 gold
I'm not much of a believer in TA. This is why I stack when ever gold is near or below the trend line:
http://www.caseyresearch.com/gsd/sites/default/files/Gold%20Trend%20Line.jpg
Clearly we could be $1300 to $2000 and nothing out of the ordinary would be occurring IMO.
@XTY I don't think they can pull the same accounting trick again
Each of the last two times they've bumped up against the debt limit, which by the way wasn't previously an independent event because it was handled when they passed a budget! Disgusting Harry Reid has refused to pass a budget in the senate for more than 3 years because they don't want to be so clearly on the record as having supported the debt they've foisted on everyone.
Sorry, had to get that off my chest. Anyway, the last couple of times they've drawn down any money they had, including social security in order to gain more time before absolutely having to deal with the debt limit. I don't think they'll want to approach an election telling senior citizens that the money for their checks is just a political football and it'll be played with whether they like it or not. Even the U.S. mainstream media, the ultimate lap dogs, will talk about it.
@GL
I see your point. I spend most of my waking hours on blogs, learning, planning, prepping, stacking. It can easily give one "SHTF fatigue." I've tried to moderate my online time but things are moving so fast now that we're watching history unfold in real-time.
One thing I've come to believe is that the likelihood of a singular SHTF moment is less than the incremental march of tyrrany were currently experiencing. Everyone is waiting and watching for the Reichstag moment, when in the past 30 days numerous little events (EPA Regs killing bacon in Michigan, for one of but many examples) continue to erode our freedoms.
I may be totally wrong and one day we'll wake up to the same programming on all 800 channels, telling us that our USD has been devalued 80% overnight and martial law and bank holidays were implemented WYWS. But I doubt it, and even if it does come, I feel prepared to weather the first round of die-offs. I was the guy taking my surplus ice around to my customers after Ike, driving my care with the air on while whistling since I had 30 gallons of gas put up while others stood in two-hour lines at Chevron. Prep on, grasshopper.
GL
I could fix up that over ground, under ground typo thing for you, if you'd like. Up to you. Let me know.
MY ARTICLE COMES OUT TOMORROW...
CRITICAL FACTORS THAT WILL IMPACT SILVER
It gave me extra inspiration after listening to Turd and Andy to finish my article. I agree whole-heartedly with Andy and his views on gold and silver. It is simply amazing how MSM propaganda can even infiltrate gold and silver bugs here and on other websites. My article is to explain how some of this MSM rubbish does not pass the SMELL TEST.
Here is one chart from my article. There are 15 charts and graphs:
The notion that INCREASED inventories on the COMEX will impact the price of silver is a meaningless. I prove this with historical examples. Gold and Silver Sentiment have to be controlled as all the US Dollar has backing it is confidence.... or the lack thereof.
The article comes out tomorrow on many internet Financial websites.
abguy4 - stackers being winded
I don't see why people find its so difficult to forget about. Its like buried treasure man. Buy it, bury it, forget about it. I'm not winded at all. Maybe I'm just an aceeption to the rule, but whoever feels weak, you really need to grab a hold of yourself. Its not that difficult to buy it and forget about it. Get some courage, have a little back bone.
Its definitely coming.
Monedas lol that is hilarious!
re Miners
I am lifting a comment made on another site by "Bowskill" who signed off as John. It struck me as genuine, if so the content is important and it was an insight not available to premier analyst Jeff Christian writing as Metalfacts to whom John is responding...
Several pages back, MetalsFacts wrote:
I have a close friend who was a senior geologist and moved up to managing gold mines in Australia, South America, North America and Africa. He told me that costs are divided into cash expenses and capital expenses. He more or less concurs that operating cash expenses are around the US$600 mark pretty much in any mine. However the "capital expenses" are usually understated and the actual total costs per ounce comes in between $1000 and $1300. The real bottom line profit margin is more like 15% than 100% in many cases. He says a sustained drop in gold price much below US$1500 per ounce will start to see mines mothballed and production cease. For that reason, miners believe there is a higher floor to gold prices than many think.
Energy costs are about 30% of cash expenses or around $180/ounce currently.
The reason that "capital expenses" are understated is the way miners go looking for capital investment to open new mines. They write a prospectus to financiers hilighting the cash expenses and hiding the real capital costs in the fine print, thereby giving the impression that the investment is safe.
This information was given to me over a beer, but it was from the horses mouth.
@Mod Washington
That will be fine.
My writing in general has alot (I mean much) to be desired. With all the professors and educators hanging around this place, I might have to pull out my third edition of Strunk and White.
GL
Done.
Ah, yes...a classic for sure.
GL
It is a tough crowd - but I think most of us are after the same thing - some truth in a sea of misinformation. And using language precisely helps us form correct ideas.
But I only corrected you there because what you say needs to be repeated:
TPTB want the gold under and over the ground.
As if a superhero could be wrong in substance!
XTY, I agree with you! Good
XTY,
I agree with you! Good communication skills is important. Nothing wrong with raising the bar. I'm not offended. Thank you!
Never far when I was at school:
Fowler's Modern English Usage
Henry Watson Fowler, R. W. Burchfield
@S Roche Some Homework
Excellent discussion, very informative and full of learning (except of few personal attacks/fights).
As I made my silver chart as a copy/paste from about 10 years past silver action at some point which before that point matched in pattern the pattern before March 13, 2011, and the silver bubble in May I saw coming, just changing time/value scales to match the current scales, and PROJECTED forward i.e. copy pasted its part that went beyond the matching part, i can say that due to the charts accuracy so far:
The markets at that point of time and in that time and value scale were manipulated almost EXACTLY in the same way as TODAY.
Does not say much for increased manipulation argument. In fact, the pattern I took from past was in much smaller time/value scale, almost unnoticeable.
What was common , though, both before current (after 2008) and then market action there was a shock event that brought EXTREME cooperation (groupthink, herding) in all markets that later , in silver market, deco operated (individual participants looking after their interests in more and more divergent ways) in the same way, producing the same pattern.
What my idea was, each market as a system has its distinctive way to decooperate ( seen in price over time chart pattern) after shock events, which should more or less repeat itself every time these shock events lead to ultimate freezing, or herding, of market at question.
Similar to an eg analog electronic circuit: by putting a delta impulse at the input, the circuit based on its internal "black box" structure will give similar output every time, on any scale as long as it stays linear ( i.e. input amplitude is not too big/small). The black box action on delta impulse or sharp loss/gain in value= Heaviside step function ( shock event) will then be described by a single analog parameter =chart =so called transient response function.
If the system ( market) internal structure (and that includes everything) does not change much during time, it will always respond the same way. Well , of course, real shocks differ very much, but some of them are so strong that action on market can be considered similar.